City of Marietta 205 Lawrence Street Post Office Box 609 Marietta, Georgia 30061 A SI Marietta Meeting Minutes MARIETTA HISTORIC BOARD OF REVIEW David Freedman, Chairman Christopher G. Brown, Vice Chairman Dorothy Woodruff, Secretary Ty Tumlin, Board Member Jim Trimble, Board Member Jesse D. Bonner, Jr., Board Member Ward 6-Open Martin Kendall, Board Member Johnny M. Walker, City Council. At Large Monday, February 3, 2025 5:30 PM Marietta City Hall Council Chambers Present: David Freedman, Jesse D. Bonner, Christopher G. Brown, Ty Tumlin, Johnny M. Walker, Jim Trimble, Martin Kendall, Dorothy Woodruff Absent: Stacy Smith (R), Staff Present: Shelby Little, Planning & Zoning Manager Sarah Ciccone, Zoning Administrator Cloe Helms, Urban Planner Rachel Langelotti, Downtown Project Manager Joseph Atkins, Board Attorney Sandra Lloyd, Board Secretary CALL' TO ORDER: Chairman Freedman called the meeting of the Historic Board of Review to order at 5:30PM. MINUTES: City of Marietta Page 1 Printed on 2/18/2025 4:59:05PM MARIETTA HISTORIC BOARD OF Meeting Minutes February 3, 2025 REVIEW 20250029 Regular Meeting Minutes Review and approve the January 2, 2025 Historic Board of Review regular meeting minutes. A motion was made by board member Walker, seconded by board member Trimble, that the January 2, 2025 Historic Board of Review regular meeting minutes be Approved as Amended to add the meeting attendance information. The motion carried by the following vote: Vote 8-0-0 BUSINESS: 20250086 50 Powder Springs Street- Exterior Changes, Paint Applicant, Aaron Peter, is seeking approval for exterior changes to the design of5 50 Powder Springs St: New Paint to closely match the existing color. Addition of a canopy and awning-Flat soffit canopy on the front entry; fabric canopy on the back entry. Replacement/Addition to the storefronts on both the front and back entrances. Replace existing front windows with a folding window system. Replace existing back entry door with new storefront system. All frames will be finished to match the existing storefronts. AI motion was made by board member Trimble, seconded by board member Woodruff, that this item be Approved and Finalized. The motion carried by the following vote: Vote 8-0-0 City of Marietta Page 2 Printed on 2/18/2025 4:59:05PM MARIETTA HISTORIC BOARD OF Meeting Minutes February 3, 2025 REVIEW 20250162 Unscheduled Appearances-Historic Board of Review The following applicants have requested to be heard as "walk-ons" or unscheduled appearances at the February 3, 2025 Historic Board of Review regular scheduled meeting. 20250117 - 58-70 South Park Square Exterior Changes-Roof 20250118 - 30 South Park Square Exterior Changes-Roof 20250119 - 91 Church Street Exterior Signage-Eden Smoothies 20250120 - 91 Church Street Exterior Signage (Windows)-Eden Smoothies 20250121 - 91 Church Street Exterior Changes Paint-Eden Smoothies 20250117 30 South Park Square-Parcel ID 16121840010- Exterior Changes-Roof Applicant, Herbert S. Goldstein Family Limited Partnership (Philip M. Goldstein), is seeking approval for new roof, gutter, copping, cap etc., and vent replacements if needed. Materials used as indicated on the application for certificate of approval. AI motion was made by board member Brown, seconded by board member Woodruff, that this item be added to the agenda. The motion was Approved and Finalized and carried by the following vote: Vote: 8-0-0 A motion was made by board member Walker, seconded by board member Trimble, that this item be Approved as amended on the agenda and Finalized. The motion carried by the following vote: Vote: 8-0-0 20250118 58-70 South Park Square-Parcel ID 16121840040-Exterior Change-Roof Applicant, Herbert S. Goldstein Family Limited Partnership (Philip M. Goldstein), is seeking approval for new roof, gutter, copping, cap etc., and vent replacements if needed. Materials used as indicated on the application for certificate of approval. AI motion was made by board member Walker seconded by board member Trimble, that this item be added to the agenda. The motion was Approved and Finalized and carried by the following vote: Vote: 8-0-0 City of Marietta Page 3 Printed on 2/18/2025 4:59:05PM MARIETTA HISTORIC BOARD OF Meeting Minutes February 3, 2025 REVIEW A motion was made by board member Walker, seconded by board member Tumlin, that this item be Approved as amended on the agenda and finalized. The motion carried by the following vote: Vote 8-0-0 20250119 91 Church Street-Eden Smoothies- Exterior Signage Applicant, Eden Smoothies (Chris Beck), is seeking approval for new exterior signs. Signs will be made of 34" PVC painted white, and stud mounted to the wall and secured with clear silicone. Also, approval for an 18'x18' blade sign made from weather resistant aluminum. AI motion was made by board member Woodruff, seconded by board member Trimble that this item be added to the agenda. The motion was Approved and Finalized and carried by the following vote: Vote: 8-0-0 AI motion was made by board member Walker, seconded by board member Tumlin, that this item be approved as amended to withdraw the blade sign from the application and approve the wall signage only. The motion was Approved as Amended and Finalized. The motion carried by the following vote: Vote 8-0-0 20250120 91 Church Street-Eden Smoothies-Signage Applicant Eden Smoothies (Chris Beck) is seeking approval to add white vinyl lettering to storefront glass (signage). A motion was made by board member Brown, seconded by board member Bonner, that this item be added to the agenda. The motion was Approved and Finalized and carried by the following vote: Vote: 8-0-0 Ar motion was made by board member Walker, seconded by board member Bonner, Jr., resulting in a "No Action Vote". Vote 4-4-0 City of Marietta Page 4 Printed on 2/18/2025 4:59:05PM MARIETTA HISTORIC BOARD OF Meeting Minutes February 3, 2025 REVIEW A second motion was made by board Chairman Freedman, seconded by board member Walker, that this matter be Approved as Amended as follows: Left window will have "eden" only. Left door will have the height reduced by removing some wording and leaving the following words listed vertically: Smoothies juices bowls eats [Fresh] clean] [yum] [organic]. Right door will have the height reduced by condensing the hours to read: Monday-Friday 8:30am-7, Sat 9-7, Sun 11-6 with the web address below. Right window with slogan (wording) to remain as presented in the application. The second motion passed with a vote of 6-2-0 with board members Kendall and Trimble opposing. 20250121 91 Church Street-Eden Smoothies Applicant, Eden Smoothies-Chris Beck- is seeking approval for painting the storefront with SW7551(Greek Villa), which is a touch lighter than Roycroft Mist Gray (SW-2844). Painting will be from ground to roof and inside of column on left to outside of column on right. A motion was made by board member Kendall, seconded by board member Woodruff, that this item be added to the agenda. The motion was Approved and Finalized and carried by the following vote: Vote: 8-0-0 A motion was made by board member Walker, seconded by board member Trimble, that this item be Approved as amended by adding the addition of the relocation of the lights (they will be moved up to accommodate the wall signage. The motion was. Approved as Amended and Finalized. The motion carried by the following vote: Vote 6-2-0 Freedman and Brown Opposed. City of Marietta Page 5 Printed on 2/18/2025 4:59:05PM MARIETTA HISTORIC BOARD OF Meeting Minutes February 3, 2025 REVIEW ADJOURNMENT: Chairman Freedman adjourned the meeting at 6:25 PM Iw - A. David-Freedman, Chairman - h Sapdra Lloyd, Secretary City of Marietta Page 6 Printed on 2/18/2025 4:59:05PM