TOWN OF JUNO BEACH FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 TOWN COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES Council Chambers - 340 Ocean Drive and YouTube December 17, 2024 at 5:30 PM PRESENT: PEGGY WHEELER, MAYOR DDHALPERN, VICE MAYOR MARIANNEI HOSTA, VICE MAYOR PROTEM DIANA DAVIS, COUNCIMEMBER LEONARD RUBIN, TOWN ATTORNEY EMILY ALVES, FINANCE/HR DIRECTOR ANDREA DOBBINS, PROJECT COORDINATORRISK MANAGER STEVENJ,HALLOCK, DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC WORKS STEPHEN MAYER, PRINCIPAL PLANNER CAITLIN E. COPBLAND-RODRIGUEZ, TOWN CLERK ALSO PRESENT: FRANK: DAVILA, INTERIM TOWN MANAGER AUDIENCE: 36 CALLTOORDER -5:30PM PLEDGE ALLEGIANCE TO THE. FLAG ADDITIONS, DELETIONS, SUBSTITUTIONS TOTHE AGENDA Mayor Wheeler; Vice Mayor. Halpern, and Councilmember Davis gave consensus toj pull Consent Agenda Council, gave unanimous consensus to move Item #13 to #18B; and. Item #15 after Item #12. Item #12 and move it to the first Action/Discussion Item. PRESENTATIONS 1. Ceremonial Swearing in ofl Police Office Todd Ostuni COMMENTS FROM THE TOWN MANAGER, THE TOWN ATTORNEY, AND STAFF MOTION: Davis/Halpern. made ai motion toj proceedwith ONMJfor engineering services for the Pelican Lake North Gazebo and authorize the Interim Town. Manager to execute the contract. ACTION: The motion, passed unanimously. COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC AII Non-Agenda items are limited to three (3) minutes. Anyone wishing to speak is asked to complete a comment card with their name and address prior to the start of the meeting as well as state their name and address for the record when called upon to speak (prior to addressing the Town Council). Town Council will not discuss these items at this time. Public Comments Opened at. 5:48PM. Public Comments Closed at. 5:53PM. CONSENT AGENDA 2. Approval ofTown Council Meeting Minutes - November 13, 2024 3. Approval of Special Town Council Meeting Minutes November 20, 2024 4. Approval ofTown Council Public Interview with Town Manager Finalist Jay Boodheshwar 5. Approval ofTown Council Public Interview with Town Manager Finalists Darren Coldwell & Minutes - December 3, 2024 Patrick Comiskey Minutes - December 4, 2024 6. Approval of Special Town Council Meeting Minutes - December 6, 2024 7. Special Town Council Meeting Minutes for December 12, 2024 8. Special Event Request - Classics by the Sea Road Runners 9. Discussion on Town Manager Job Description 10. Year to Date (YTD) Financial Statements 11. Resolution 2024-24 (PBA Collective Bargaining Agreement) MOTION: Halpern/Davis made a motion to approve the consent agenda as amended. ACTION: The motion passed unanimously. COUNCIL ACTION/DISCUSSION ITEMS 12. 2025 Health Insurance Renewals MOTION: Halpern/Hosta made a motion to approve the Florida Blue BlueCare S14354 HMO Plan as the base employee health insurance plan, The Solstice dental plan, FMIT vision plan, the health care Flexible Spending Accounts, and opt-out provisions as outlined above for the planyear 2025, effèctive January 1, 2025 to December. 31, 2025. ACTION: The motion passed. 3-1 with Councilmember Davis opposed. 15. Special Event Request - Art Fest by the Sea MOTION: Davis/Hosta made ai motion to approve the request. for the. special event proposedin Juno Beach as stated above, subject to the applicant being responsible for the application process of the special event and all conditions and requirements following said application, including any additional eyrrinepoalpses ACTION: The motion passed unanimously. 14. Discussion on Traffic Concerns (U.S. Highway One and Donald Ross Road) MOTION: Davis made ai motion to have staff write a letter to oppose the lane widening until the master, plan is complete. ACTION: The motion. failed) for lack ofasecond. Noj further action given on this item. 16. Caretta Project Gateway Plaza Features Council gave unanimous consensus to have staffsend out ai Polco survey to the citizens for input on artwork for the Caretta Plaza; and to have the developer proceed with the fountains. 17. Selection ofCode Rewrite Consultant Code Rewrite consultant. MOTION: Halpern/Davis made ai motion to approve Chen Moore and. Associates' (CMA) as the ACTION: The motion, failed. 2-2 with. Mayor Wheeler and Vice Mayor Pro Tem Hosta opposed. MOTION: Halpern/Davis made a motion to select Chen Moore and Associates' (CMA) as the Code Rewrite consultant and have them provide an itemized cost sheet for each task for future consideration by the Council. ACTION: The motion passed unanimously. 18. Atlantic Boulevard Roadway Improvements Project MOTION: Davis/Hapern made a motion to approve a Contract with. J.W. Cheatum LLC in the amount of $56,217.20 for the construction of the Atlantic Boulevard Roadway Improvements project and a determination that the obtaining three written quotations is not the best interest of the Town. ACTION: The motion passed unanimously, 18B. Filling ofVacant Seat #3 Andrew Spilos announced his name withdrawalfrom consideration. Council conducted a ballot method to. select from the list ofcandidates (see attached) and then gave unanimous consensus to. select John Callaghan toj fill vacant seat #3 until March 2026. MOTION: Davis made a motion to hire. Jay Boodheshwar, for the position of Town. Manager: Council gave unanimous consensus to direct Colin Baenziger & Associates to restart the. search 19. Continued Discussion on Selection ofTown Manager ACTION: The motion, failed) for lack ofasecond. for the position of Town. Manager. COMMENTS FROM THE COUNCIL Vice Mayor Pro Tem Hosta provided her resignation letter as Vice President oft the Ecology Group (see Council, gave unanimous consensus to have staff Fwork with the TPA on the Complete Streets impact; and toa adda discussion on their trafic concerns to the. January agenda; and have staff draf a letter opposing attached). the minimizing of the Donald Ross Road median. ADJOURNMENT Mayor Wieeler adjourned the meeting at 9:20PM. Caitlin A Peggy Whèeler, Mayor E. Copelind-Rodriguer, E pCS #13 -7 4o GeTbnngé MG Gmail Caitlin Copeland ccopeland@juno-Deach.fl.us) Please read my comments at council meeting tonight public comments Siobhan O'Donnell creinc@gmai.com> Tue, Dec 17at11:58AM To: Town Of Juno Beach Caitlin Copeland Rodriguez, MMC, Clerk <CCopeland@juno-beach.f.us>, <town.counci@uno- Achange is desperately needed in Juno Beach Town Government. Peggy Wheeler was able to grab the Mayor's seat only as a result of her police foundation friends smearing and slandering the former mayor. Tens of thousands of dollars from dark money political PACS besieged our mailboxes with lies and slander all designed to scare residents into voting for Wheeler. She has spent every day since that horrifying election ended in March 2024 by paying back the favors she received. She just tried to ram through a vote on the christmas tree lot which involved breaking the laws and rules of our Town and iti is being challenged in Court. She broke federal law by violating the First Amendment Rights of citizens who tried to speak out at the meeting where the vote on the christmas tree lot took place. And she never reported the thousands spent to get her the votes. The damage to the reputation of Juno Beach is increasingly being harmed by her failures and incompetence. And today Wheeler has deliberately blocked the rights of citizens in this town to vote for the candidate of their choice to fill the empty Council Seat. And she and Diana Davis have refused to accept the remaining Top Candidate for Town Manager, Darren Coldwell, an honest and highly qualified Town Manager who would clean up the Town's underhanded methods of doing business. This scares Wheeler and Davis and they are blockColdwell. We need a change and : support applicant Andy Spilos for the empty Council seat. Andy graduated from Florida State University with a degree in Public Administration. His political experiencel includes managing political campaigns from the local level to the Florida House and Senate. Andy worked on Congressional campaigns also. Andy is extremely aware of the problems facing our town and he has been involved and participating in town issues. Andy was appointed to the Audit Review Committee where he serves now. He is a local business owner with experience in retail managment and understands what it takes to run al business. Andy would bring a common sense approach to dealing with thei issues and he would be open to base his decisions on what the residents think is best for the Town. Above all else, Andrew Spilos is ar man of integrity who would not be working for the interests of anyone else except the citizens of the Town. Council beach.fl.us> Members please choose integrity please choose Any Spilos. [Quoted text hidden] 12/17/24, 11:51A AM Town of Juno Beach Mail- Form submission from: PUBLIC COMMENTS Gmail Caitlin Copeland ccopeland@uno-Deach.fi.us) Form submission from: PUBLIC COMMENTS Town of Juno Beach Florida uno-peach-i@municodewep.com> Reply-To: Town of. Juno Beach Florida copelandeunoeanaus Submitted on Tuesday, December 17, 2024- - 10:39am Submitted by anonymous user: 76.108.220.137 1r message Tue, Dec 17, 2024 at 10:39/ AM To: copan@uno.oncnnus Submitted values are: First Name Cyndie Last Name Wolf Address 440 STARLIGHT LN Email Address chwolt@rocketmal.com Agenda Item Number (Ex: 1,2, 3)Public Comment Public Comment/ / Question Itruly hope that those of you who went to the resident funded staff and volunteer holiday party enjoyed yourselves. Ireally do! But as Ihave said before, choosing to include some volunteers and not inviting others, in my opinion, was al huge mistake. Your exclusion of the Planning and Zoning members and the Audit Committee members who make a significant contribution toi thet town on their own time and at their own expense exacerbates the divided town we have become. Facilitative and transformational leadership that we: SO desperately need ini this town, was absent in this decision. Ifit was ar money issue, the spouses, partners, and others could have been excluded instead. It should have been a fully inclusive staff and volunteer celebration. Given another opportunity in the future, hope you willl be more thoughtful. The results of this submission may be viewed at: hitps/wuno-beachilusnod2951submssion/19853 htps./lmai.google.com'malluonk-s4ad0a186vewepisearch-alspermtl"8186506572158188597Cmsg.t18i18702598054899351.. 1/1 JUNO TOWNOF BEACH TOWN OF JUNO BEACH PUBLIC COMMENT CARD ANY CITIZEN WISHING TO SPEAK SHOULD COMPLETE THIS CARD AND GIVE IT TO THE TOWN CLERK PRIOR TO THE START OF THE MEETING. TU95 AGENDA ITEM #: DATE: PHONE NO.: NAME: HowAro Mlon CHAMBA op commera REPRESENTING (IF APPLICABLE): CU ADDRESS: Rotzryg CHECK WHAT MAY APPLY: SUPPORT OPPOSE WISH TO SPEAK WOULD LIKE MY COMMENT READ INTO THE RECORD: OF JUNO BEACH TOWN OF JUNO BEACH PUBLIC COMMENT CARD CITIZEN WISHING TO SPEAK SHOULD COMPLETE THIS CARD AND GIVE IT TO THE TOWN CLERK PRIOR TO THE START OF THE MEETING. ANY DATE: AGENDA ITEM #: PHONE NO.: 73 NAME: Lany Sinily REPRESENTING (IF APPLICABLE): 120 Ocesn Dr ADDRESS: CHECK WHAT MAY APPLY: SUPPORT OPPOSE - WISH TO SPEAK Aaybe WOULD LIKE MY COMMENT READ INTO THE RECORD: 12/17124,7:20AM Town of Juno Beach Mail Form submission from: PUBLICC COMMENTS Gmail Caitlin Copeland ccopeland@juno-beach.fl.us> Form submission from: PUBLIC COMMENTS Town of Juno Beach Florida uno-Deach-i@municodeweb.com> Reply-To: Town of. Juno Beach Florida copelancé,noeanus Submitted on Monday, December 16, 2024 - 10:03pm Submitted by anonymous user: 73.205.140.186 1n message Mon, Dec 16, 2024 at 10:03PM To: cpean.@unooacus Submitted values are: First Name Susan Last Name Van Lindt Address 504-3 Sea Oats Drive Email Address Svaninat@/cloud.com Agenda Item Number (Ex: 1,2,3).14 Public Comment/ Question Road, these are my concerns. Thank you to council for considering the traffic problems on Donald Ross Road. As someone who lives off of Donald Ross 1. Iti is difficult to pull out of and into Sea Oats when the bridge is open. Our entrance is often blocked with no traffic 2. Speed limit should be reduced and enforced. Iti is dangerous pulling out of Sea Oats. Cars travel at a high rate of speed 3. What can be done to speed up the opening and closing oft the Donald Ross bridge? When it opens twice an hour, that only allows for 1/2 hour of driving time per hour. Bridge openings average 15 minutes. PGA and Indiantown appear to be 4. Sea Oats residents have been promised a safe way to cross US1 for years. ASea Oats resident got hit by a car and died crossing that intersection. Caretta donated money to accomplish that, but funds were used instead for pavers, Please don't forget about our community's needs when considering the traffic problems on Donald Ross Road. It shouldn't enforcement. It would be beneficial for us to have at traffic light. Please consider. to get over thel bridge before it opens. half that. The town and county need to consider that is a big part oft the traffic problem. supposedly Complete streets would address safe crossing. Where is that initiative? only be about the cars passing through, changes should benefit the residents of Juno Beach. Thank you for your time and consideration. The results of this submission may be viewed at: ntps/wuno-beachlusinode2951submisson/19851 hitpslimal.google.comimail.on-slanscasshe-plsearchrandralipemihd-tivendti1eie85s.87215815a7Cmsptieles.. 1/1 o MGmail Caitlin Copeland ccopeland@juno-beach.fl.us> Form submission from: PUBLIC COMMENTS Town of Juno Beach Florida guno-beach-fl@municodeweb.com> Reply-To: Town of Juno Beach Florida Copeimdeno-MENuy Submitted on Tuesday, December 17, 2024 - 11:08am Submitted by anonymous user: 76.108.220.137 Tue, Dec 17 at 11:08AM To: <ccopeland@juno-Deach..us> Submitted values are: First Name Cyndie Last NameWolf Address/440 STARLIGHT LN Email Address Cholt@rocketmal.com Agenda Item Number (Ex: 1,2, 3)13 Public Comment / Question Town Council Open Seat With the number of residents who are stepping up to be considered for the open council seat, it seems ill advised that the council should vote on this tonight. These persons have not had the opportunity to present their credentials and no Instead of allowing for a fair and democratic election by the townspeople, Peggy says that shei feels comfortable choosing someone who has previous council experience, but that doesn't mean that that person, if they were to run for office, would necessarily be chosen again by the residents. Just because they served doesn't mean that they and their decisions were respected by the residents. And isn't the argument hypocritical at best since Peggy had no prior experience when she was Thei town needs an innovative thinker. Someone who may see a different side of things and who would represent those residents who have a different perspective and a differing vision for the town. There are those of us who would like to curb development and have zoning and codes that actually mean something. Not zoning and codes that are flexible depending Let the residents hear from these applicants who willl be representing us. No significant decisions will be made between now and the. January meeting so filling the seati is not essential at this time. hope you will table this vote until then and protocol for moving forward to fill this seat was established prior to this meeting. elected to the council. So the point is not as poignant as you had hoped. on what the developer is willing to bribe the town with in return for ai favor. establish steps forward for these applicants. The results of this submission may be viewed at: itps/wwjuno-beachilusynode29518ubmission/19854 12/17/24, 11:49AM Town of Juno Beach Mail- Form submission from: PUBLIC COMMENTS Gmail Caitlin Copeland copalanc@lunoacntu Mb Form submission from: PUBLIC COMMENTS Town of Juno Beach Florida juno-beach-I@municodeweb.com> Reply-To: Town of. Juno Beach Florida cpeancélunocsanu Submitted on Tuesday, December 17, 2024-1 11:49am Submitted by anonymous user: 174.48.187.87 1r message Tue, Dec 17,2024 at 11:49AM To:c copean@uno.beachlus Submitted values are: First Name Deli Last Name Torres Address311 Ocean Drive Email Address imdgt@aol.com Agenda Item Number (Ex: 1,2,3)13 Public Comment/ / Question Ihave spoken in person at the P&Z meeting against the Pulte development and giving them ROWI land and l'am not in agreement in the direction this town is headed. The behavior of some council members is quite concerning. The recent resignations are also troublesome. These meetings ati times when people work, is also quite unfortunate. Currently, the town has a vacant seat on town council and needs to hire a town manager. The residents should have the opportunity to vote on a new town council member. The town council asked the neighbors to meet with the candidates for Additionally, Iwould be very interested in a resident poll asking residents what times are convenient for meetings (among Aslmentioned, lattended a P&Z meeting and Ifelt very judged by my concerns and my point of view. Many other residents feel their views are not being considered. This process is shutting out residents who are opposed to over development and residents who have other suggestions and concerns. Something needs to change. The residents of this community should feel comfortable how this town moves forward andi feel safe to voice their concerns or input. Therefore, town manager, the same: should be done for town council members. other questions) and how to establish a standard of ethics for our town council and town manager. we should all be voting for at town council member and town manager. Hoping for a more resident involved solution The results oft this submission may be viewed at: htps/wuno-beachilusmode29lsubmssion/9857 htps/imail.goole.comimail.vork-cla-oo.sshverplsarcdrard-alipemino-rvend#i1e85s.857215818547Cmaptisie/04.. 1/1 13 M"Gmail Caitlin Copeland ccopeland@juno-beach.fi.us> sa Form submission from: Contact Us Town of. Juno Beach Florida <uno-beach-fl@municodeweb.com> Reply-To: Town of Juno Beach Florida <ccopeland@)uno-Deach.fl.us> Submitted on Tuesday, December 17, 2024 - 11:33am Submitted by anonymous user: 76.110.86.19 Tue, Dec 17 at 11:33AM To: CCpNdAmocNIN Submitted values are: First Name Bianca Last NameGiancoli Email gancoli@yanoo.com Question/Comment Open Seat in the council Please read this comment during the meeting tonight: While Ifirmly believe that residents should have the opportunity to select the new council member for the open seat through a fair and open election, if the responsibility falls to the remaining council members to make this decision, Andy brings an impressive blend of education, experience, and dedication to our community. As a graduate of Florida State University with a degree in Public Administration, he has a strong foundation in government processes and public service. His extensive political experience includes managing campaigns at every level, from local races to the Floridal House and Senate, as well as Congressional campaigns. This background gives Andy a unique understanding of the challenges and What sets Andy apart is his active involvement in town matters and his commitment to our community. Hei is acutely aware of the problems we face and has already demonstrated his dedication by serving on the Audit Review Committee this year. Andy's business experience as the owner of ar real estate photography company, combined with 11 years in retail management, reflects his ability to successfully run al business, make strategic decisions, and manage resources Most importantly, Andy would bring a common-sense approach to the Council. He is not aligned with any special interest groups, and his decisions would be guided by what is truly best for the residents of our town. While he would serve as one member of the Council, his integrity, experience, and pragmatic outlook would make him a valuable addition to the team, For these reasons, if the Council must appoint someone to fill the open seat, lurge you to consider Andy Spilos, a candidate who combines experience, independence, and a clear commitment to the future of our town. strongly suggest Andy Spilos for the role. intricacies of public leadership, as well as the skills to navigate the complex issues facing our town. efficiently--skills that are essential for any effective council member. ensuring that the voices of the residents are heard and respected. The results of this submission may be viewed at: itps/wwwjuno-beachilusynode/suubmission/9856 JUNO BEACH OF TOWN OF JUNO BEACH PUBLIC COMMENT CARD ANY CITIZEN WISHING TO SPEAK SHOULD COMPLETE THIS CARD AND GIVE IT TO THE TOWN CLERK PRIOR TO THE START OF THE MEETING. >o AGENDA ITEM #: 13 NAME: Aahygpk DATE: 1z/7/24 PHONE NO.: REPRESENTING (IF APPLICABLE): 5e5 ADDRESS: CHECK WHAT MAY APPLY: SUPPORT OPPOSE h WISH TO SPEAK WOULD LIKE MY COMMENT READ INTO THE RECORD: TGWNOF JUNO BEACH TOWN OF JUNO BEACH PUBLIC COMMENT CARD ANY CITIZEN WISHING TO SPEAK SHOULD COMPLETE THIS CARD AND GIVE IT TO THE TOWN CLERK PRIOR TO THE START OF THE MEETING. DATE: PHONE NO.: MSRE AGENDA ITEM #: 13 NAME: BGibel 1alz/y REPRESENTING (IF APPLICABLE): ADDRESS: 457 Olympnes CHECK WHAT MAY APPLY: SUPPORT - OPPOSE TO SPEAK Bmsn IWOULD LIKE MY COMMENT READ INTO THE RECORD: MG Gmail Caitlin Copeland ccopeland@juno-beach.fl.us> Form submission from: PUBLIC COMMENTS 'Town of. Juno Beach Florida' via Council <town_counci@uno-Deach.f.us> Reply-To: Town of. Juno Beach Florida ccopeland@juno-beach.f.us) Submitted on Tuesday, December 17, 2024 -9 9:37am Submitted by anonymous user: 73.205.141.20 Tue, Dec 17a at 9:37AM To: town.counci@uno-beach.f.us> Submitted values are: First Name Anita Last NameBloom Address900 Ocean Dr Email Address bipomanineoutok.com Agenda Item Number (Ex: 1,2, 3)Town Manager Public Comment/ Question loffer ai few comments on the town manager situation. Earlier this month, thet field of candidates for Town Manager was narrowed to two finalists. As an interested resident with extensive executive hiring experience, Iwas interested ini this process. Iread the candidate materials, watched the recorded interviews, read comments from other residents, and let the information percolate. Though Ihad no initial strong preference, my mind kept replaying Darren Coldwell's kindly phrased observation that Council Meetings typically last until 10:30 or later, which is not efficient. Mr Coldwell observed that people get weary after af five hour meeting, and arel less ablei to make optimum decisions. Hes suggested that some functions could be delegated to staff. inc over regulation and little benefit for the community. Upon reflection, things started to "click" in terms of oddities I'd noticed ini the workings of our town. Inmy observation, the way our town presently operates, staff appears to expend a lot of effort on busy work which results For example, one staff project of the past year focused on new regulations required when al homeowner adds an outside Why? Because twice a year, someone complains to Town hall about ar neighbor's light disturbing them. At thet timel I Ironically, during the Town Manager interview process, council members expressed concerns about attracting and keeping talented staff. This begs the question - If all at talented person is entrusted with is low value busy work, why would there Ithink iti is increasingly evident that council and town processes need a rework. dont blame anyone for the condition we are in, as our dysfunction is clearly baked into our habits. Sadly, Isee al lot of "busy work" everywhere. Notably, on several occasions during the interviews, council members asked questions along the lines of light. became aware of this initiative, marveled at the sheer wastefulness. be any job satisfaction. No wonder we have talented people taking their leave. lalso see confusion as to proper assignment of roles and responsibilities. "How would you set priorities" "How would you establish a vision" he would facilitate. that found him, Mr. Coldwell gently responded thati iti is Council's rolei is to set priorities and establish a vision, after which he outlined how How extraordinary itis to have a candidate demonstrate his expertise sO concisely during during the interview process. Ift this situation presented itself in my corporate life, would grab Mr. Caldwell as fast as possible and thank my lucky stars Though it may be difficult to discern for council members accustomed to the present dysfunction, The exact right candidate is standing in front of you. In my view, Mr. Coldwell has demonstrated that - He is an excellent diagnostician, intuitively discerning our keyi issues While he has an eagle eye, he also has al kind and generous demeanor Especially after perusing the Page, Arizona web site, He is clear on who should be doing what - and this clarity enables him tot focus like al laser on productive change. Ifeel confident Mr. Coldwell is capable of guiding our town through changes that will benefit everyone. Hel has accomplished remarkable things for Page, and done iti in a way that gives credit and praise to all participants. lencourage Council to heed the message that Providence has provided, and grab Mr. Coldwell before someone else snaps him up. The results of this submission may be viewed at: itpswwwjeno-beachilusnode295laubmisson/19852 12/17/24, 11:51 AM Town of. Juno Beach Mail- Form submission from: PUBLIC COMMENTS Gmail Caitlin Copeland sccopeland@uno-Deach.f.us) Form submission from; PUBLIC COMMENTS Town of Juno Beach Florida uno-beach-I@municodewe.com> Reply-To: Town of Juno Beach Florida ccpeancénoceans Submitted on Tuesday, December 17, 2024-1 11:16am Submitted by anonymous user: 76.108.220.137 1message Tue, Dec 17,2024 at 11:16AM To: copean@unoeachus Submitted values are: First Name Cyndie Last Name Wolf Address 440.STARLIGHTLN Email Address wor@rocketmal.com Agenda Item Number (Ex: 1,2,3).19 Public Comment/ / Question lam sincerely embarrassed for the town after the convoluted search for a new town manager. Ity was truly embarrassing for the town and insulting to the candidates. Darren Coldwell was the last man: standing and he was treated disrespectfully int the end. Marianne was right when she said that contacting Jay Boodheshwar, after he had rejected the townto see if Marianne has suggested that Frank be considered for the position. In all fairness to the town's residents, if you go ahead with this idea, he must present a resume and be fully vetted as the other candidates were. He should be required to present at formal application and go through the consultant andi follow the same protocols as anyone else interested in the position. Iwould want to know his educational background, work experience, accomplishments and references just as we required oft the other candidates. It would be important for residents to hear his vision for thet town during an interview. hey would reconsider, was beyond. The results of this submission may be viewed at: ntps/wwuno-peachlusnode295lsubmissionn9855 htps.lmail.google.com/malluo7k-daed0a586vewepiasearchealapemmnnd-thvead1818658586550657219818547Cms9.t1818704959382584492.. 1/1 TOWN OF JUNO BEACH FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 BALLOT hst RANK(1-4) NAME (Alphabetical by Last Name) BUTLER, JONATHAN CALLAGHAN, JOHN COTRONAKIS, ELAINE. K. SPALOSANDREW Signature: Print Name & Titer_ Uuke Date: 12-1 & TOWN OF JUNO BEACH FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 BALLOT NAME (Alphabetical by Last Name) BUTLER, JONATHAN CALLAGHAN,OHN COTRONAKIS, ELAINE! K. SPILOSANDREN RANK( (1-4) Signature: Print Name & Title: Date: TOWN OF JUNO BEACH FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 BALLOT NAME (Alphabetical by Last Name) BUTLER, JONATHAN CALLAGHAN, JOHN COTRONAKIS, ELAINE. K. SPILOS,ANDREW. RANK(1-4) Signature: cTariosn Bbt Print Name & Title: MARINNE HOSTA VICEAAYOR PRO TEM Date: 12-1/24 TOWN OF JUNO BEACH FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 BALLOT NAME (Alphabetical by Last Name) BUTLER, JONATHAN CALLAGHAN, JOHN COTRONAKIS, ELAINE K. SPOS,ANDREWA RANK(1-4) DiouGDavisg Signature: Print Name & Title: Date: 12-17 TOWN OF JUNO BEACH FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 BALLOT TAL RANK(1-4) NAME (Alphabetical by Last Name) BUTLER, JONATHAN CALLAGHAN, JOHN COTRONAKIS, ELAINEI K. SPILOS, ANDREW 1111 11 Signature: 1C ) Print Name & Title: SRtc OALA TM, Date: i217(24 TOWN OF JUNO BEACH FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 BALLOT NAME (Alphabetical by Last Name) BUIHERONATHAN CALLAGHAN,JOHN COTRONAKIS, ELAINE K. SPILOS,ANDREW RANK (1-4) Signature: Cha Print Name &Title: Mayor Date: 1Z-7-Z074 TOWN OF JUNO BEACH FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 BALLOT NAME (Alphabetical by Last Name) BUFHERONATHAN CALLAGHAN, JOHN COTRONAKIS, ELAINE K. SPIEO5,ANDREW RANK (1-4) Signature: Print Name & Title: 217 BapirA 121724 Date: TOWN OF JUNO BEACH FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 BALLOT NAME (Alphabetical by Last Name) BUPEEIIONATHAN CALLAGHAN,OHN COTRONAKIS, ELAINEI K. SPILOS,ANDREW RANK (1-4) Signature: Print Name & Title: Clashan Shl Date: nfn/g TOWN OF JUNO BEACH FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 BALLOT NAME (Alphabetical by Last Name) BUREEKJONATIANE CALLAGHAN, JOHN COTRONAKIS, ELAINE. K. SPHLOS,ANDREW RANK (1-4) Signature: Dibmaas Print Name & Title: Date: TOWN OF JUNO BEACH - FLORIDA INCORPORATED 1953 BALLOT TTAL RANK(1-4) NAME (Alphabetical by Last Name) BURLERONATHAN CALLAGHAN,JOHN COTRONAKIS, ELAINE! K. SPILOS,ANDREW Signature: Print Name & TiterRAK AuL Date: 4z/224 Rovdadl by Maname Hoska Subject: Resignation as Vice President of the Ecology Group To the Board of the Juno Beach Ecology Group, Ihereby submit my resignation as Vice President of the Ecology Group, effective As both Diana Davis, the current President, and Is serve on the Town Council, I feet iti is best to step back to avoid any conflicts related to the Sunshine Law and to lextend my best wishes to the entire board and its members, both long-standing and new. With the fresh talent now involved, I am confident the group will continue Iwill always look back fondly on the earlier years when DD Halpern, Michael Clarjen, and Jim Ferguson were part of our mission. At that time, five or six years ago, we were a small team of enthusiastic novices dedicated to rehabilitating Pelican Lake's flora and fauna. It was truly a labor of love - an innocent, honest, and sincere effort to restore life to the lake after it had been damaged by chemicals. Iremain deeply grateful for having been part of that mission. Thank you for the opportunity to serve alongside you and contribute to this December 17, 2024. preserve my ability to vote on ecological matters in the future. to thrive under its current leadership and new direction. meaningful cause. Sincerely, Marianne Hosta