BOROUGH OF GETTYSBURG TROXELL COUNCIL CHAMBERS 59EASTHIGH STREET, GEITYSBURG, PA 17325 COUNCIL WORK SESSION MINUTES  NOVEMBER 25, 2024  President Matthew Moon called the meeting to order at 7:00 PM with the following Councilors present: Vice-President Judith Butterfield, Mr. Peter Bales, Ms. Alisha Sanders, and Mr. Chad-Alan Carr. Councilors absent: Ms. Patricia Lawson, Mr. Christopher Berger, and Mayor Rita Frealing. Staff present included: Borough Solicitor Harold Eastman, Barley Snyder; Borough Manager Charles Gable; Borough Secretary Sara Stull; Planning Director. John Whitmore; and] Public Works Director Robert Harbaugh. Staff not present included: Police Chief Robert Glenny; Coordinator of Historic and Environmental Preservation Debra English; Chad Clabaugh Borough  Engineer, C. S. Davidson, Inc.; and Parking Manager Rebecca Fissel.  Others present included: Jill Sellers, President of Main Street Gettysburg; David Rice, Chairman of the Shade Tree Commission, 145 West Broadway; Nancie Gudmestad, Owner of the Shriver House Museum, 309 Baltimore Street; Brian Hodges, 137 Ridge Avenue: William Mooney, III, Good Samaritan Lodge #336, 9 Lincoln Square; Bill Mooney, 151 West High Street; Emily Warren, Trip to the Cottage, 90 Chambersburg Street; Lawrence Weindorf42 York Street; and filming  by Community. Media-ACCTV.  President Matthew Moon announced A Gettysburg Christmas Festival will be held on Friday, December 6th through Sunday, December gth 2024. Information and the schedule of events can be located on1 the Borough Website at itips/www.AGettsburgChnsmassrestival.com,  President Matthew Moon announced that the 2025 Budget Proposal is posted on the Borough Website at wwwetyspurgpagov and a copy is available in the Borough office lobby for  public review. Special Presentation  President Matthew Moon said that McKenzie. Johnson, Co-Responder with the York/Adams Mental Health-Intellectual and Development Disabilities (MH-IDD) Program had a family emergency and was unable to attend tonight's meetings, but will give a presentation at a future meeting. He explained that the mental health co-responder has been collaborating with the police department for about two years and has been successful in working with the public. The program is an important initiative that was funded by grants through WelISpan Health and is a partnership  with York/Adams MH-IDD.  Public Comment (Restricted to items appearing on the agenda - not tabled items)  Nancie Gudmestad, Owner of the Shriver House Museum, 309 Baltimore Street asked that the Council consider closing thej parking spaces in front ofHotel Gettysburg, One Lincoln Square during the Tuba Fest thati is scheduled for the second weekend in] December. She said that they expect approximately 500 people to attend the annual event which would crowd people onto the streets as  Council Work Sessionl Minutes November! 25, 2024 Page 1of5    inj prior years.  President Matthew Moon said that Borough staff is planning to close these spaces for the Bill Mooney, 151 West High Street expressed his concern about the clutter on1 the sidewalks which includes A-frame signs, store clutter, contractor and political signs. These things obstruct the sidewalks and often times there is not enough space for pedestrians to walk. He is in favor oft the. A- Frame signs that shows events, bands, store specials, etc. He asked ifthere is an ordinance: regulating  safety of the people in attendance.  the square feet a business can use on1 the sidewalks.  Current and Old Business  PBS 2016-12 Sidewalk Ordinance Revisions  President Matthew Moon said that the Sidewalk Ordinance Revisions was al big project that Borough Council decided to undertake this year. At that time, the Borough did not realize the severity of the conditions of the sidewalks and how costly it would be to repair them. During tonight'si meeting he said that the Council will discuss the sidewalks and how they intersect with the Shade Tree Ordinance, sidewalk clutter and outdoor dining. He said that the Shade Tree Commission was asked this summer toj provide Council with an inventory of the trees, and are present tonight to  give a report on their findings.  1. Shade Tree Ordinance. /Procedures  David Rice, Chairman of the Shade Tree Commission, 145 West Broadway presented Council with a 2024 Shade Tree Census Report outlining the addresses, species and the condition of the trees and noted that the last survey of trees was completed in 2009 (see attached). He said that he and Shade Tree Member Susan Naugle walked the streets to complete the tree survey which took several months to compile. They also looked at the sidewalks during this time toi record the: sidewalks that are damaged from the trees. Some were heaved-up by one-and-a-halrinches and would need to be shaved down for pedestrian safety. He pointed out that the Public Works Department has begun anew technique when planting trees by placing a root barrier around the tree, and the Shade Tree Commission is also choosing trees more carefully that are less likely to raise the sidewalks. As part ofl last year's Shade Treel budget, they allocated $5,000 oft their $20,000 budget to be used for a pilot program to look for concrete solutions for the sidewalks. He contacted Conewago Construction to prepare a quote to shave sidewalks that are heaved-up and the costs to replace them. The quote was $2,100 per day to review the sidewalks on which they will start on Baltimore Street, which is the worst street in town. They plan to do this work before the end of this year. The Shade Tree Commission's plan for the 2025 season is to include implementing a pilot program to purchase and plant trees on private property where the sidewalks are not suitable for trees. The trees would only bei made available to consenting property owners, and then they would be responsible for any future maintenance or removal oft the tree. He said that they hope that Council will be in favor of the pilot  program proposal.  President Matthew Moon thanked the Shade Tree Commission members David Rice and  Council Work Sessionl Minutes November 25, 2024 Page2of5    Susan Naugle, which are all volunteers, for all the work in compiling street information and completing the tree survey. He said the information will be helpful to review the worst sidewalk areas to make an assessment that could be a capital project for the Borough to undertake. He asked Council members what they thought oft the pilot program that the Shade Tree Commission wants to  pursue by working with property owners to place trees on their properties.  Councilwoman Sanders said that the pilot program is a great idea and that she would approve the Shade Tree Commission working with property owners to plant trees on their property  with the understanding that the home owners would be responsible for the trees.  Councilman Carr said that he is grateful for all the volunteer work that the Shade Tree Commission put into this report and he would support the pilot program. He said that his only reservation is that he does not believe that the Shade Tree Commission makes a recommendation to Borough Council to vote on tree placement and feels that this procedure should be considered. bring together both community members and the homeowners to participate ini it.  Councilwoman Butterfield said that she: feels the pilot program is a great idea and it would Councilman Bales said that he approves of the pilot program as long as the property owners Shade Tree Member Susan Naugle said that as the Borough Council reviews and updates the Sidewalk Ordinance it would be helpful ifthe Shade Tree Commission could be included ini this process since it intertwines with the tree program. She also noted that the Shade Tree Ordinance needs to be reviewed and updated as well, and that they plan to reach out to other municipalities to  consent to maintaining the trees.  gather information and copies oft their tree ordinance.  President Matthew Moon asked for the Shade Tree Commission to present their recommendations to Borough Council for consideration in the 2025 Legislative Priorities. Manager Gable asked if the Shade Tree Commission is aware of any other communities that plant trees outside of the municipalities rights-of-way; and noted another concern would be about the legality of a tree placed on someone's property that causes damage or hits someone whether the Borough would be responsible. He said that this is something we will need to consider  and review. 2.  Sidewalk Clutter/A-Frame Signs and Outdoor Dining / Street Furniture President Matthew Moon said that sidewalk clutter has been discussed for several years about how signage can create: impediments, and explained that the sidewalks must be compliant with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). This was discussed briefly during the Sign Ordinance Revision discussions and noted that portable signs located on or near public sidewalks must maintain aminimum width ofi five feet ofunobstructed area between the sign and any other objects that might impede pedestrian traffic. He pointed out that ADA mandates the five-feet width to be compliant. The sidewalk clutter is not only signs but furniture, merchandise, sandwich boards, etc. Borough Council and Staff is currently working with the Borough Solicitor to produce a Citation Ordinance  Council' Work Sessionl Minutes November 25, 2024 Page 3of5    that would allow the Code Compliance Officer to address these obstructions and to be able to issue citations. He noted that he has seen sandwich boards in the middle oft the sidewalk and that there is not five feet on either side, SO they are already in violation of the current Sign Ordinance which is  often unenforced.  Councilman Carr said that it is difficult because not all sidewalks are the same size and Borough needs to maintain the five-feet width to be in compliance with ADA. He said that the Borough may need to take the same approach as the Shade Tree Commission and review each street for the sidewalk size, but then it would not be the same throughout town limiting businesses as to what they are allowed toj place on the sidewalk. He said then this could possibly create al legal issue. President Matthew Moon said that ift the sidewalks are: not wide enough to bei in compliance with ADA then the signs, tables and chairs etc. cannot be placed on those sidewalk areas. He said that we have implemented dimensional standards in the past but also need to empower the Code  Compliance Officer to enforce and allow the issuance of citations as a last resort.  Manager Gable said that there is currently an Outdoor Dining Ordinance in which a business would apply to the Borough for the placement of tables and chairs in the public right-of- way. The Borough Staffreviews the application and measures the space to: make sure that it is ADA compliant before approval. He said other things to consider would be if someone wants to place just chairs in public right-of-way would they need to get the Borough'sp permission; and noted that tree wells and  stairs or step units also impede onto the sidewalks. the enforcement managed for the sidewalk clutter.  Councilman Bales asked ift the Code Compliance Officer is not allowed to enforce orl how is President Matthew Moon responded that the Code Compliance Officer can enforce these issues, but what Borough is currently drafting an ordinance that would empower him toi issue citations for repeat offenders. He said that there are some regulations already inj place, but said that they may  need to be more stringent.  Councilwoman Sanders said that she agreed with Councilman Carr that we should do an assessment oft the sidewalks first because all sidewalks are not the same size. We need to make sure that we are in compliance with ADA for all impediments to include signs, outdoor furniture, clutter, etc. The language in the ordinance should also be cleaned up to make it clear to the businesses as to  what is permitted and what is not.  Manager Gable said that he agrees that we need to define the space better and what the Councilman Bales expressed his concern that the smaller businesses might get boxed out due tot the limited space, and ifthey get issued citations that could be detrimental to them. He asked about the flags placed along the sidewalks that hang down and hit you as you walk by and wondered ifthe  impediments and clutter are and also what types of things that would be allowed.  Code Compliance Officer would manage this.  President Matthew Moon responded that the Code Compliance Officer has been  Council Work Session! Minutes November: 25,2024 Page 4of5    extraordinary about informing people of the issues first and then collaborating with them to get it corrected. The citations would only be issued as a last resort. He said that most oft the flags are in  violation by state law stating that they must be seven feet offt the ground.  Councilman Carr said that he feels the current guidelines are fine and does not think itr needs to be more stringent as long as we meet the ADA requirements. He said that the Code Compliance Officer needs to be more involved with enforcement, and ifl he is then that presents an issue ifl he is  being ignored.  President Matthew Moon said at the beginning ofthe year the Code Compliance Officer did enforce certain sidewalk issues, but is now waiting on Council's decision regarding revisions to the  Sidewalk Ordinance and about the citation mechanism.  Councilman Carr said that the Borough was very loose during the COVID Pandemic, which is understandable, but needs to rein things in and follow our guidelines for ADA compliance. The Council needs to allow the staff and the Code Compliance Officer to educate businesses about the  sidewalk regulations.  Councilwoman Butterfield said that ADA compliance: is notj just for wheelchair accessibility Councilman Carr agreed and said that everyone needs to be able to navigate the sidewalks  but also for pedestrians walkability.  with ease. New Business  There was no new business.  Public Comment (Open to items currently tabled or not listed on the agenda)  David Rice, Chairman of the Shade Tree Commission, 145 West Broadway said that Shade Tree Member Martin Jolin said that there should be a five-foot passage for pedestrians on the  sidewalks. Adjournment  President Matthew Moon dismissed the meeting at 8:15 PM.  Respectfully submitted, SmkostlL  Saral L. Stull Borough Secretary  Council Work SessionMinutes November: 25, 2024 Page 5of5    AA Classifiers AAA Column count Baltimore St. Bender Baltimore St. Bender Baltimore St. 2F Plaza Baltimore St. 15 Baltimore St. 28 Baltimore St. 34 Baltimore St. 47 Baltimore St. 104 Baltimore St. 117 Court House Baltimore St. 117 Court House Baltimore St. 117 Court House Baltimore St. 117 Court House Baltimore St. 133 Baltimore St. 135 Baltimore St. 143 Baltimore St. 150 Library Baltimore St. 150 Library Baltimore St. 150 Library Baltimore St. 150 Library Baltimore St. 205 Baltimore St. 208 Baltimore St. 217 Baltimore St. 220 Baltimore St. 223 Baltimore St. 224 Baltimore St. 229 Baltimore St. 231 Baltimore St. 238 Baltimore St. 240 Baltimore St. 241 Baltimore St. 247 Baltimore St. 261 Baltimore St. 264 Baltimore St.: 271 Baltimore St. 301 Baltimore St. 303 Baltimore St. 304 Baltimore St. 312 Baltimore St.3 316 Baltimore St.: 317 Baltimore St. 333 Baltimore St. 333 Baltimore St. 336 Baltimore St. atl Lefever Barlow St40  Good Fair Poor Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Poor Good Good Good Poor Good Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Good Good Fair Good Good  <6" 6-122-2424" <6" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" 12-24" >24" >24" 6-12" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" <6" >24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" >24" >24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" <6"  OK 75-1.5.75-1.5" OK >1.5" OK >1.5" OK .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK >1.5" OK .75"-1.5" OK 75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" .75"-1.5" >1.5" OK >1.5" >1.5" >1.5" >1.5"  0 ??? Zelkova Linden Elm, Chinese Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Locust Ginkgo Yellowwood Yellowwood Yellowwood Yellowwood Locust Locust Locust Elm, Field Elm, Field Elm, Field Elm, Field London Plane Tree Pear Maple, Silver??? Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Ash, Green Oak, Pin Ash, White Oak, Pin Ash, Green Maple Elm, Frontier Gingko Linden Pear, Capital Zelkova Linden, Little leaf Linden, 'Greenspire' Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Locust Gingko Gingko Hophornbeam London Plane Tree Spruce  460  2 323 84 50 0 56 113 103 25 0 581 45 40 0  Poor  >1.5" >1.5"  Poor  >1.5" >1.5"  Poor  Poor Poor Poor  OK OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" >1.5" OK OK OK  Breckenridge 2(301 Baltimore) Yellowwood Breckenridge 2(301 Baltimore) Yellowwood Breckenridge 2(301 Baltimore) Yellowwood Breckenridge 2(301 Baltimore) Yellowwood Breckenridge 2( (301 Baltimore) Yellowwood Broadway, E @ 500 Hbg Rd. Broadway, E @ 500 Hbg Rd.  Oak, Pin Oak, Pin    Broadway, E 2@ 435 Carlisle Broadway, E 2@ 435 Carlisle Broadway, E 36 Broadway, E 39 Broadway, E 46 Broadway, E 50 Broadway, E 50 Broadway, E 61 Broadway, E 66 Broadway, E 76 Broadway, E 84 Broadway, E 84 Broadway, E 88 Broadway, E 88 Broadway, E 121 Broadway, E 121 Broadway, E 125 Broadway, E 141 Broadway, West 2 Broadway, West 29 Broadway, West 29 Broadway, West 30 Broadway, West 30 Broadway, West 35 Broadway, West 35 Broadway, West 38 Broadway, West 38 Broadway, West 49 Broadway, West 49 Broadway, West 50 Broadway, West 50 Broadway, West 55 Broadway, West 114 Broadway, West 135 Broadway, West 135 Broadway, West 135 Broadway, West 140 Broadway, West 140 Broadway, West 140 Broadway, West 159 Broadway, West 251 Infirmary Broadway, West 251 Infirmary Carlisle St. 10Pub Carlisle St. 10Pub Carlisle St. 11 Hotel Carlisle St. 18 Carlisle St. 28 Carlisle St. 102 Carlisle St. 106 Carlisle St. 116-118 Carlisle St. 120-122 Carlisle St. 124 Dr. Atkins Carlisle St. 125 Monahan Carlisle St. 125 Monahan Carlisle St. 125 Monahan Carlisle St. 125 Monahan Carlisle St. 140  Poplar, Tulip Poplar, Tulip Dawn Redwood Cherry Elm, Chinese London Plane Tree London Plane Tree Sweetgum, round Sweetgum, round Maple, Red Poplar, Tulip Poplar, Tulip Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Zelkova Zelkova Pear, Aristocrat Maple, Silver??? Ash, White Oak, Willow Oak, Willow Linden, Silver Zelkova Oak, Pin Sweetgum Linden, Silver Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Maple, Red Cherry, Kwanzan Cherry, Yoshino Cherry, Yoshino Cherry, Yoshino Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Cherry, Yoshino Dogwood, Kousa Walnut??? Linden Zelkova Sweetgum, Round Leaf ??? ??? Zelkova Zelkova Zelkova Linden Locust Ginkgo Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Maple, Red  Good Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Good Good Good Good Fair Good Good Poor Fair Fair Fair Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Good Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Good Poor Poor Poor Fair  <6" OK <6" OK <6" OK <6" OK <6" OK 6-12" OK 6-12" OK <6" OK <6" OK <6" OK <6" OK <6" OK 12-24" OK 12-24" OK <6" OK <6" OK 12-24" OK 12-24" OK OK 12-24" OK 6-12" OK >24" >1.5" >24" OK 12-24" OK 12-24" 75"-1.5" 12-24" >1.5" 12-24" >1.5" 12-24" >1.5" 12-24" .75"-1.5" 12-24" OK 12-24" OK 12-24") OK 12-24" OK 12-24" .75"-1.5" 6-12" OK 6-12" OK 6-12" OK 6-12" OK <6" OK 12-24" 75"-1.5" 12-24" >1.5" 6-12" OK <6" OK >24" OK 6-12" OK <6" OK <6" OK <6" OK <6" OK 6-12" OK 6-12" OK 6-12" OK 6-12" .75"-1.5" 6-12" OK <6" OK 12-24" OK 12-24" OK 12-24" OK <6" OK  Broadway, E 89@444Harisburg Rd Cherry Broadway, E 89@444Harisburg: Rd Cherry  Poor Poor    Carlisle St. 140 Carlisle St. 140 Carlisle St. 140 Carlisle St. 143 Carlisle St. 153 Sun City Carlisle St. 202 Carlisle St. 204 Carlisle St. 240 Sigma Chi Carlisle St. 250 Carlisle St. 250 Carlisle St. 250 Carlisle St. 250 Chambersburg St. 1T&S Chambersburg St. 2A.C.Bank Chambersburg St. 2A.C.Bank Chambersburg St. 2A.C.Bank Chambersburg St. 20 Chambersburg St. 21 Chambersburg St. 22 Chambersburg St. 27.5 Chambersburg St. 28 Chambersburg St. 35 Blue Parrot Locust Chambersburg St. 45 Chambersburg St. 51/53 Chambersburg St. 60 Chambersburg St. 61,7-11 Chambersburg St. 101 Chambersburg St. 110 Chambersburg St. 111Bank Chambersburg St. 114 Chambersburg St. 115 Chambersburg St. 116 Chambersburg St. 117 Chambersburg St. 125 FOE Chambersburg St. 130 Chambersburg St 131 Chambersburg St. 135 Chambersburg St. 136-138 Chambersburg St. 143 Chambersburg St. 146 Chambersburg St. 150 Chambersburg St. 153 Chambersburg St. 201 Chambersburg St. 221 Chambersburg St. 226 Chambersburg St. 233 Chambersburg St. 239 Chambersburg St. 243 Chambersburg St. 46 Culp St, side Best Western Culp St, side Best Western Culp St., side Best Western Culp St., side Best Western Culp St, side Best Western Fairview Ave. 956 Fairview Ave. 956 Fairview Ave. 956 Fairview Ave. 956 Fifth Street 49  Maple, Red Maple, Red Maple, Red Zelkova? Zelkova Honeylocust Honeylocust Maple, Norway Ginkgo Sweetgum Sweetgum Sweetgum Linden, Little Leaf Linden Linden Linden Linden Oak, Pin Linden Locust Locust Zelkova Zelkova Lilac tree, Ivory Silk London Plane Tree Locust London Plane Tree London Plane Tree Locust Locust Maple, Red Zelkova Zelkova Maple, Red Zelkova Zelkova Maple, Red Linden Zelkova Japanese Pagoda Tree Sweetgum Oak Linden London Plane Tree Pear, Capital Maple, Red Beech, European Lilact tree, Ivory Silk Honeylocust Honeylocust Honeylocust Honeylocust Honeylocust Pear Pear Pear Pear Maple, Silver  Fair Fair Poor Good Good Good Good Poor Fair Fair Fair Good Fair Poor Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Good Good Good Good Fair  <6" <6" <6" <6" <6" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" <6" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24") <6" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" <6" 6-12" <6" 6-12" <6" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" <6" >24" 12-24" 6-12" 12-24" <6" <6" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" <6" 6-12" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24"  OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" .75"-1.5" .75'-1.5" OK  3  Poor  >1.5" >1.5"    Fourth St. 240 Franklin St. North, east side Franklin St. North, east side Franklin St. North, easts side Franklin St. North, east side Franklin St. South 5 Franklin St. South 5 Franklin St. South 5 Franklin St. South 42? Franklin St. South 44 Hanover St. 225 A+ Mini Mart Hanover St. 225 A+ Mini Mart Hay St. North, 35 Hay St. North, 35 Hay St. North, 47 Hay St. North, 47 High St. West 1-3 High St. West 1-3 High St. West 1-3 High St. West 47 High St. West 47 High St. West 135 High St. West 141 High St. West 143 High, E 2Library High, E 2Library High, E 2Library High, E 34 Trinity Church High, E 34 Trinity Church High, E 34 Trinity Church Highland Ave. 644 Highland Ave. 1138 Howard at 55 Seminary Howard at 55 Seminary Howard at 55 Seminary Howard at 55 Seminary Howard Street 32 Howard Street 36 Howard Street 37 Howard Street 37 Johns Ave. at McDonalds Johns Ave. at McDonalds Johns Ave. at McDonalds Johns Ave. atl McDonalds Liberty Street@165 York St Liberty Street@165) York St Liberty Street@165) York St Lincoln Ave., West 49 Lincoln Ave., West 49 Lincoln Ave., West 155 Lincoln Ave., West 155 Lincoln, E 109 Lincoln, E 109 Lincoln, E115 Lincoln, E209 Lincoln, E360 Lincoln, E360 Lincoln, E3 360 Lincoln, E 360  Pin Oak Oak, Red Oak, Red Oak, Red Oak, Red Pear, Callory Pear, Callory Pear, Callory Pear, Aristocrat Honeylocust Maple, Red Zelkova Maple, Red Maple, Red Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Ash, Patmore Crepe Myrtle Crepe Myrtle Maple, Red Maple, Red Pear, Callory Pear, Callory Maple, Norway Crepe Myrtle Crepe Myrtle Crepe Myrtle Maple, Hedge Maple, Hedge Maple, Hedge Sycamore Ginkgo Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Cherry Zelkova Maple, Norway Maple, Sugar Pear, Valiant Pear, Valiant Pear, Valiant Pear, Valiant Catalpa Ginkgo Ginkgo Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Cherry Japanese Maple Dogwood Maple, Sugar Sweetgum, Round Leaf Locust Hornbeam, Eu. Locust  Fair Good Good Good Good  12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" 12-24" >24" >24"] 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12"  OK OK 75"-1.5" .75"-1.5" .75"-1.5" OK .75"-1.5" .75"-1.5" .75"-1.5>1.5" .75"-1.5>1.5" OK OK OK .75"-1.5" .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK >24" OK >24" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" OK .75"-1.5" OK OK  Poor Poor Poor Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Poor Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Poor Good Good Good Fair Fair Fair Good Good Fair Good Fair Fair Good Poor Poor Poor Poor Poor Poor Good Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good  >1.5" >1.5"  >24" >24"  6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" <6" 6-12" 6-12" <6" <6" <6" <6" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12"  >24" >24"  >1.5" >1.5" .75"-1.5" .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK    Long Lane 819 Long Lane 819 Long Lane 819 Long Lane 962 Long Lane 962 Long Lane 962 Long Lane 962 Middle St. East 15 Middle St. East 15 Middle St. East 19 Middle St. East 34 Middle St. East 34 Middle St. East 54 Middle St. East 101 Middle St. East 106 Middle St. East 118 Middle St. East 118 Middle St. East 126 Middle St. East 140 Middle St. West 58 Middle St. West 66 Middle St. West 101 Middle St. West 101 Middle St. West 145 Middle St. West 148 Middle St. West 152 Middle St. West 217 Kennie's Middle St. West 217 Kennie's Middle St. West 217 Kennie's Middle St. West 217 Kennie's Middle St. West 217 Kennie's Middie St. West 217 Kennie's Middle St. West 217 Kennie's Mummasburg St 22 Mummasburg St. 22 Mummasburg St. 23 Mummasburg St. 26 Mummasburg St. 31 Mummasburg St. 31 Mummasburg St. 31 Reynolds 25 Reynolds at 97 Springs Reynolds at 97 Springs Seminary Avenue 55 Seminary Avenue 55 Seminary Avenue 55 Seminary Avenue 55 Seminary Avenue 116 Seminary Avenue 116 Seminary Avenue 116 Seminary Avenue 128 Seminary Avenue 141 Seminary Avenue 141 Seminary Avenue 150 Seminary. Avenue 150 Seminary Avenue 153 Seminary Avenue 156  Pear, Aristocrat Pear, Aristocrat Pear, Aristocrat Pear Pear Pear Pear Maple Maple Maple Locust Locust Pear Maple Pear, Bradford Honeylocust Honeylocust Pear, Bradford Zelkova Lilact tree, Ivory Silk Honeylocust Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Oak, Pin Hophornbeam Hophornbeam Elm, Chinese Elm, Chinese Elm, Chinese Elm, Chinese Elm, Chinese Elm, Chinese Elm, Chinese Zelkova Zelkova Zelkova Zelkova Zelkova Zelkova Zelkova Maple, Red Crepe Myrtie Crepe Myrtle Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Oak, Pin Locust Locust Locust Locust Elm, Lacebark. Allee Maple, Red Cherry Cherry Rose of Sharon Cherry  Good Fair Poor Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Poor Good Good Fair Good Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good  12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" 6-12" 12-24" <6" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" <6" <6" <6"  OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK >1.5" .75"-1.5" >24") OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK >24" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK Ok OK OK >1.5" OK .75"-1.5" 75"-1.5" .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK  5 >1.5" >1.5"  >1.5"  Middle St. West 1 Opp.Court House Yellowwood Middle St. West 10pp.Court House Yellowwood  >1.5"  6-12" <6" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" <6" <6" <6" 12-24"  >24" >24"  >24" >24" >24" >24"  <6" <6" <6" <6" 12-24" <6" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12"  >1.5"  Poor    Stratton, South 2St.. James Stratton, South 2St. James Stratton, South 40A A.Crouse Stratton, South 40A.Crouse Stratton, South 98 Stratton, South 102 Stratton, South 102 Sunset Avenue 848 Sunset Avenue 848 Sunset Avenue 848 Sunset Avenue 848 Sunset Avenue 848 Sunset Avenue 848 Sunset Avenue 907 Sunset Avenue 907 Sunset Avenue 907 Sunset Avenue 999 Wash., North 48 Wash., North 63 7-11 Store Wash., North 63 7-11 Store Wash., North 63 7-11 Store Wash., North 63 7-11 Store Wash., North: 209 Wash., North 211 Wash., North 215 Wash., North 243 Wash., North 247 Wash. St. South 6 Wash. St. South 10 Wash.St. South 10 Wash.St. South 12 Wash.St. South 18 Wash.St. South 24 Wash.St. South 31 Wash.St. South 31 Wash.St. South 131 Wash.St. South 137 Wash.St. South 137 Wash.St. South 137 Wash.St. South 211 Wash.St. South: 211 Wash.St South 219 Wash.St. South 219 Wash.St. South 225-227 Wash.St. South 229-231 Wash.St. South 233 Wash.St. South 240 Wash.St. South 248 Wash.St. South 253 Wash.St. South 256 Wash.St. South 268 Wash.St. South 302 Wash.St. South 302 Wash.St. South 302 Wash.St. South 302  Crepe Myrtle Crepe Myrtle Serviceberry Ginkgo Maple, Red Hornbeam, American Maple, Norway Pear, Chanticleer Pear, Chanticleer Pear, Chanticleer Pear, Chanticleer Pear, Chanticleer Pear, Chanticleer Pear Pear Pear Pear Linden, Littieleaf Lilac Tree, Ivory Silk Lilac Tree, Ivory Silk Lilac Tree, Ivory Silk Lilac Tree, Ivory Silk Hawthorn London Plane Tree London Plane Tree Zelkova Zelkova Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Linden Linden Hawthorn Ginkgo Ginkgo Honeylocust Maple, Norway Hawthorn, Winter King Hawthorn, Winter King Maple, Hedge Hawthorn, Winter King Maple, Hedge Hawthorn, Winter King Hornbeam, Eu. Elm Maple, Red Pear, Chanticleer Elm Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American  Good Good  <6" <6"  OK OK OK OK OK 75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK 75"-1.5" OK OK OK >1.5" .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK  7  Good Good Good Good Good Good Poor Fair Fair Fair Fair Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Poor Fair Poor Fair Fair Poor Fair Fair Fair Fair Good Good Good Fair Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Good Good Fair Fair Poor  12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" <6" 6-12" 6-12"  Wash., North 2 @101 Chambe. Maple, Hedge Wash., North 2 @101 Chambe. Maple, Hedge  >1.5"  6-12" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12"  Wash.St. South 100 @ 66 WMi. Honeylocust Wash.St. South 100@66 w. Mid. Honeylocust, Shademaster    Wash.St South 302 Wash.St. South 325 Wash.St. South 325 Wash.St. South 326 Wash.St. South 332 Wash.St. South 338 Wash. St. South 344 Wash.St. South 404 Wash.St. South 406 Wash.St. South 410 Wash.St. South 410 Wash.St. South 432 Wash.St. South 432 Wash.St. South 450 Wash.St. South 450 Wash.St. South 450 Wash.St. South 508 Wash.St. South 712 Wash.St. South 712 Wash.St. South 714 Dobbin Wash.St. South 714 Dobbin Wash.St. South 714 Dobbin Wash.St. South7 714 Dobbin Wash.St. South@ 100 Chamber. ?? Wash.St. South@ 100 Chamber. ?? Wash.St. South@ 100 Chamber. ?? Water St. West2 24 Water St. West 45 Water St. West 45 Water St. West 63 Water St. West 63 West Street, 126 York Street 10 PNC Bank York Street 17 Moose York Street 17 Moose York Street 30 York Street 33-35 York Street 39 York Street 39 York Street 39 York Street 44 Brafferton Inn York Street 49 York Street 58 York Street 59 York Street 60 York Street 108 York Street 109 St. James York Street 109 St. James York Street 109 St. James York Street 112 York Street 117 York Street 118 York Street 127 York Street 128 York Street 131 York Street 134 York Street 135 York Street 140 Knorr Antiques York Street 141  Hornbeam, American Hawthorn, Winter King Hawthorn, Winter King Elm Zelkova ??? Elm Hornbeam, Eu. Hombeam, Eu. Homnbeam Hornbeam Hawthorn Hawthorn Maple, Hedge Maple, Hedge Maple, Hedge Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American Hornbeam, American  Good Good Fair Good Good Good Good Fair Poor Good Good Good Good Good Good  12-24" OK 12-24" OK OK OK 6-12" OK OK 6-12" OK 12-24" OK 12-24" OK OK OK 6-12" OK 6-12" OK 6-12" OK 6-12" OK <6" OK 12-24" 75"-1.5" OK OK 12-24" OK 12-24" OK 6-12" OK 12-24" OK >24" >24" OK >24" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK OK .75"-1.5" OK OK  Poor Poor Fair Fair Good Fair Good Good Poor Poor Poor Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good  >1.5"  Zelkova Linden Linden Maple, Silver Zelkova Maple, Gingerbread hybrid Cherry, Snow Goose Yellowwood Yellowwood Locust Birch, River Lilact tree, Ivory Silk Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Honeylocust Elm, New Horizon Ginkgo Ginkgo Cherry, Japanese London Plane Tree Honeylocust Honeylocust Honeylocust London Plane Tree Lilac tree, Ivory Silk London Plane Tree Zelkova Zelkova Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Maple, Red Lilac tree, Ivory Silk Locust  <6" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" <6" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" <6" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 12-24" <6" 6-12" 6-12" <6" 6-12" 12-24" 12-24" 12-24" 6-12" <6" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12" 6-12"  Poor  >24"  Poor    York Street 146 R. McGlaughlin York Street 149 York Street 150 Tom McKenny York Street 156 York Street 162 York Street 165 York Street 165 York Street 210 Yellow House York Street 218 York Street 225 A+ Mini Market York Street 225 A+ Mini Market York Street 240 York Street 302 TEM Inc. York Street 302 TEMI Inc. York Street 304 TEMI Inc. York Street 304 TEM Inc. York Street 316 York Street 316 York Street 324 York Street 615 Schmucks York Street 615 Schmucks York Street 615 Schmucks York Street 615 Schmucks York Street 687, Tire Center York Street 8 York Street 8 York Street 9  Lilact tree, Ivory Silk Lilact tree, Ivory Silk Zelkova Elm, New! Horizon Maple, Red Gum, Black Maple, Red Maple, Red Maple, Red Maple, Hedge Honeylocust Zelkova Ash, Purple Ash, Purple Ash, Purple Ash, Purple Ginkgo Hawthorn, Winter King Honeylocust Cherry, Okame Cherry, Okame Hawthorne, Black Cherry, Okame Cherry, Okame Elm, Chinese Elm, Chinese Elm, Chinese  Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Fair Fair Fair Fair Good Poor Good Fair Good Good Good Good Good Good Good Good  6-12" OK 9 6-12" OK 6-12" .75"-1.5" <6" OK 6-12" OK <6" OK 12-24" OK 6-12" OK <6" OK 12-24" OK <6" OK 12-24" OK 12-24" OK >24" OK 12-24" OK >24" OK <6" OK 6-12" .75"-1.5" >24" OK <6" OK <6" OK 6-12" OK <6" OK <6" OK 6-12" 6-12" 6-12"  Poor    Count by Species  2009 2024 34 0 2 0 1 0 3 1 3 0 0 11 34 0 17 1 86 0 6 1 24 38 4 163 2 110 272 0 1 0 1 12 8 2 6 16 859 51 808  Ash Beech Birch Box Elder Buckeye Catalpa Cherry Cottonwood Crepe Myrtle Dawn Redwood Dogwood Elm Gingko Gum Hawthorn Hop-hornbeam Hornbeam Japanese Maple Japanese Lilac Tree Japanese Pagoda Tree Linden Locust London Plane Tree Maple Mountain Ash Oak Pear Poplar, Tulip Rose-of-Sharon Serviceberry Spruce Sweetgum Sycamore Walnut Yellowwood Zelkova  9 1 1 1 0 1 22 0 11 1 3 28 15 1 12 5 36 1 32 1 21 45 13 57 0 42 48 4 1 3 1 9 1 1 18 43 488  Less Long Lane  Red = trees planted recently    Planted Street  SPedeO3SPAdEA  1  Broadway, West 2 Bradford Pear Broadway, West 2 Bradford Pear Broadway, West 2 White Ash  White Ash  Broadway, West 29 Willow Oak Willow Oak Broadway, West 29 Willow Oak Willow Oak  Spring 07 Broadway, West 30 Zelkova, Green Zelkova, 'Green Vase' Spring 07 Broadway, West 30 Linden, Silver Linden, Silver  Broadway, West 35 Pin Oak  Pin Oak  Broadway, West 35 Sweet Gum Sweet Gum  Spring 07 Broadway, West 38 Linden, Silver Linden, Silver  Broadway, West 38 Pin Oak Broadway, West 43 Sugar Maple Broadway, West 49 Pin Oak Broadway, West 49 Pin Oak Broadway, West 49 Pin Oak Broadway, West 49 Pin Oak Broadway, West 50 Pin Oak Broadway, West 50 Pin Oak Broadway, West 50 Pin Oak Broadway, West 50 Pin Oak Broadway, West 55 Pin Oak Broadway, West 55 Pin Oak Broadway, West 55 Pin Oak Broadway, West 114 Pin Oak Broadway, West 138 Norway Maple Broadway, West 138 Norway Maple Broadway, West 138 Norway Maple Broadway, West 140 Pin Oak Broadway, West 140 Pin Oak Broadway, West 140 Locust Broadway, West 201 Pin Oak Broadway, West 201 Pin Oak  Pin Oak Pin Oak Pin Oak  Pin Oak Pin Oak  Pin Oak  Spring 07 Broadway, West 135 Elm, Bosc  Pin Oak Pin Oak  33  16+6 new