OF City of Cambridge DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS PLANNING & ZONING 1025) Washington St. Cambridge, Maryland 21613 Telephone: 410-228-1955 Fax: 410-228-3814 HPC Agenda MARYLAND: 1684 The City of Cambridge Historic Preservation Commission will conduct an in-person meeting on Wednesday, September 18th, 2024 at 6:00 p.m at Council Chambers, 305 GayStreet. The meeting will be streamed live on Town-alStreams.com The conference call-in instructions are: Dial in: (848)-777-1500# Access the meeting online with WebEx: Access code: 83256# https/ctyoicambridgemd.webexcom/clyolcambridgemd/php/MTDD-m4049c/a35a35ca15e247058ae htips//Ctyoftambridemdwebexconyclyotambridgemsemd/php/MITD-m4049c/235a15-247058faeebd87-9 Wednesday, September 18, 20246 6:001 PM I 2h hours I (UTC-04:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada) Occurs the third Wednesday of every month effective 2/21/2024 from 6:00 PM to 8:00 PM, (UTC-04:00) Eastern e6d87c9f Time (US & Canada) Meeting number: 25535495132 Old Business Password: 5Eq24BxpM28 (53724297 when dialing from a video system) 1. Update on 301 Mill Street 2. Update on 428-432 Race Street 3. Update on deferred HPC 2025-4 1100 School Street 4. Update on deferred HPC 2025-5 120 West End Avenue 5. Update on deferred HPC2025-2 107 Willis Street 1. HPC: 2025-10 906 Locust St: Porch updates. 2. HPC: 2025-11 110 Choptank Ave: Installation of new fence. 3. HPC: 2025-12 800 Glasgow St.: Replacement Windows New Business This agenda is subject to change, the final agenda will be approved by the Commission at the Hearing. 906 Locust Street Proposed scope of work: Remove existing porch floor. Install new 2"x8" salt treated framing. Install "wolf" PVCT&G flooring (same as side and back porch recently installed). Install screen on back porch and deck. Replace existing K-style gutters with K-style gutters. Replace single wood step on front of house with brick. Remove concrete walkway on front of house and replace with brick. Install concrete apron on Oakley 610. 906 Locust Street (D-484). Two story, three bay frame house with a central entrance and a central projecting square porch tower with a gable roof. There is a hip- roofed one story porch across the front and two gabled dormers. Ca. 1890. Contributing building. B. Street side of house at driveway. Relevant Guidelines: GPF 4.7.A. Historic porches, and front steps including character defining features such as railings, posts or columns, ceilings, steps, lattice, flooring, piers, ornamental trim, and other character defin- GPF 4.7.B. Historic porch and front steps shall be repaired, rather than replaced, using materials and methods that preserves historic material, including patching, epoxy repair, reinforcing, or splic- GPF 4.7.C. If a historic porch or front steps is too deteriorated to repair, it shall be replaced in kind or in an appropriate: substitute material that matches the existing in size, shape, texture, color, and GPF 4.7.D. Replacing deteriorated or missing elements of a porch or front steps shall be based on existing elements or documentary evidence. Creating at false historical appearance, such as adding GPF 4.7.E. Enclosing open porches that are: seen from the public right of way shall not be undertak- en except for adding screening. Porches that are not seen from the from the public right of way may be enclosed or screened if the enclosure is designed and constructed in a manner that pre- ing elements shall be retained and preserved, if possible. ing-in of new wood in place of deteriorated sections. other character defining features. Victorian ornament to a plain early 20'h century porch, shall not be permitted. serves the historic character defining features of the porch. OF CAN City of Cambridge HPC-COA# PLANNING AND! ZONING 1025 WASHINGTONS STRFFT CAMBRIDGE, MARYLAND21613 THUPHONE:410.7-195 FAX:410-228-1474 MDRELAYVITT)7-- or1 -800.735-2258 ARC# EAR# MARY/LAND 1684 Application to the Historic Preservation Commission Check the. Appropriate Requested. Action: Informal Review Discuss with Staff andt the Commission preliminary design ideas fora a project. The Commission will address the appropriateness oft the proposal and provide guidance. Meet with staffto discuss projects eligible for administrative review, such as in-kind replacement of deteriorated features, minor work not impacting the architectural character, or repairs and in-kind restorations etc. (see attached Minor Work Items Chart Meet withs stafft to qualify the level of emergency of the repairs and replacements One or more Commissioner will confirm (site visit may be required): in addition to Staff Administrative Review Certificate (ARC) attached) Emergency. Approval Review (EAR) Formal Review- (Certificate of APPopTaeme/PCCOA) Requires a full review by the Historic Preservation Commission Typical projects thata apply (please check relevant sections below) Construction of any new buildings, additions, or accessory structures Exterior Building Alteration (facades, roof, porches, entrance: stoops. ) Demoltion/Movinga: Structure/Removal ofa character defining feature Signage or Graphics Landscaping/FencingPatios-Paying Other: Consent Agenda - Application is presented at HPC meting; ifCommissioners have questions, itb becomes a full HPCI review, otherwise iti is voted upon without discussion Note: Please refer to Administrative/Minor Works Item chart attached for details on HPC-COA requirements PROPERTYI INFORMATION: Address: Ann Shoemaker Map/Parcel Number Built 906 Locust St. Cambridge MD. 21613 Current Zoning Year APPLICANT INFORMATION: Name: Branden A. Spear Street Address: 5061 Maryland. Ave. Cambridge, MD2 21613 E-Mail Address: brandenspearconsinuction@gmail.com Phone Number: 410-228-5620 Number Fax Number CONTRACTOR/ARCHITECT (ifapplicable) Name: B.A.S. Construction INC Address: 506 Maryland. Ave. Cambridge, MD21613 Daytime phone number: 410-228-5620 Email address: brandenspearconstruction@gmail.com MHIC: :89629 Please indicate below which sides of the building are impacted and provide documentation as applicable: Main street front façade Side yard facades Rear façade and rear side of house Outbuildings the project. Please use the table below to indicate the existing elements that will be affected by Existing Materials Foundations & Masonry Exterior Wall/Finish Porch/Floor, Elements, Details Entrance Steps Windows & Doors type & style Omemental Elements (brackets ...) Roof& Dormers Chimmey(s) Walkway & Driveway Built Landscaping Features Fences Signage Handicapped accessibility Solar Panels Exterior lighting Quantity: 2 Scope of Work: Describe the proposed project in detail, including all changes to the building, site, or lot. Include all features to be removed, replaced, altered, repaired, and/or added. Attach more sheets to provide all drawings and to describe all Remove existing porch floor. Install new 2"x8" salt treated framing. Install "wolf" PVC T&G flooring ( same as side and back porch recently installed ). Install screen on back porch and deck. Replace existing K-style gutters with K-style gutters. Replace single wood step on front ofhouse with brick. Remove concrete walkway on front ofhouse and replace with brick. Install concrete apron on Oakley Street side of house at driveway. proposed, elements, materials and their specifications. Please complete the following checklist of required elements to complete your Attachments Checklist: In order to ensure completeness of your application, please complete the following checklist of required documentation. Any application without the necessary documentation and deemed incomplete by staff will not be accepted nor application. presented at the HPC hearing. Required Documentation: For All Applications (HPC-COA, ARC and EAR): Completed/ signed application form elevation where the work is to be completed. like after proposed work is completed. "Before" photos of existing conditions, should show the entire site, plan and "After" hotodawingerendeing: should indicate what the property will look Specifications and/or materials brochures describing in detail the manufacture, material, proportions and details ofa all new proposed elements oft repair, replacement or new construction 3 For New Construction, Addition or Demolition Site plan, to scale.. A site plan should include: property lines, lot dimensions, fence location, fence length and height, existing structure(s), existing or proposed porches, decks and outbuildings, right-of-way or access easements on the property (even ifnoti in use), distance fromj property lines, and location ofs surrounding roads. Floor Plans (showing existing conditions, demolition and new construction) Dimensioned elevation drawings of all sides affected (including any demolition & Construction Details (including all materials specifications, ornamental elements, For Fences, Porches and Site Improvements (decks, garages, sheds, new construction) special features) pergolas) Site plan, to scale. A: site plan should include: property lines, lot dimensions, fence location, fence length and height, existing structure(s), existing or proposed porches, decks and outbuildings, right-of-way or access easements on the property (even ift not in use), distance from property lines, and location of surrounding roads. Drawingyphotographs of proposed alteration and modifications to site Material specifications including picture or product brochure of proposed product, as well as specification sheet for construction materials and pre-fabricated elements Solar Panels Roof plan, to scale, showing the location of all panels on the roof Elevations of! loçations with solar panels Photos of"before", and ifj possible "after" conditions viewed from street level or rights-of-way Signage Dimensioned rawingrendering of proposed sign and placement on the building Photos of streetscape, including surrounding signage ifapplicable. 4 Modifications to mature trees and significant natural landscape features Photos of existing conditions as they relate to the streetscape Ihave reviewed, and I understand the applicable HPC guidelines for my project. Applicant/Owner Signature Date OFFICE USE ONLY Receipt #: Meeting Date: Date Received: Documents provided: 1original Fling Fees-Residential, Taken By: $50.00 HPC Application #: Commercial & Non-Residential $100. Administrative Review (No charge) Request for Extension: No charge iff filed before expiration date). Note: Make Checks Payable to the City of Cambridge. 5 906 Locust St < 8 xpoapaay o 5 3 o A E b m 0 < 3 a S C a E S 110 Choptank Ave Proposed scope of work: welded wire. -install a wooden picket fence int thei front yard and continue thei fence into the back yard using black 220. 110 Choptank Avenue. Two story, three bay frame house with a central cross gable and extension to the rear. There is Gothic window in the cross gable. Ca. 1900. Contributing building. B. GCL 5.2.B. The design new fences shall be compatible with the associated building, site, and streetscape in height, proportion, scale, color, texture, material and design. Fence types such as wire, hurricane, chain-link, corrugated metal, and wooden post and rail, and other non-traditional fence types shall not be permitted if visible from the public right of way, but may be permitted if GCL5.2.C. Fences shall not exceed a height of four feet in front and side yards or other areas that can be readily be seen from the public right of way. Fences located sO they are not readily seen otherwise located. from the public right of way may be up to six feet high. Online Form Submittal: HPC Application noreply@cwicpluscom norepyecwepluscom, To:Holly Baldwin hbaldwin@choosecambrndge.com> HRC2025-11 Fri9/6/2024 1:41PM HPC Application Step 1 Application to_the Historic Preservation Commission Consent Agenda Check the Appropriate Requested. Action: PiAppoPnatenes/HPC. fFormal Review (Certificate Landscaping/rencingPatios/Paving COA) pfOther Page 1 Field not completed. Note: Please refer to Admjinistrative / Minor Works Item chart attached for details on HPC-COA requirements PROPERTY INFORMATION Address City State Zip Code Map /Parcel Number Current Zoning Mear Built Name Email Address 110 Choptank Avenue Cambridge MD 21613 Field not completed. Field not completed. 1930 APPLICANT INFORMATION Susan & Brian Wiley prusan.wiey@gmail.com Address City State Zip Code Phone Number Fax Number Name Email Address Address City State Zip Code Phone Number Fax Number Name Address City State Zip Code paytime Phone Number MHIC or Registration Page 2 110 Choptank Avenue Cambridge MD 21613 904-333-4238 Field not completed. PROPERTY (LAND) OWNER (IF DIFFERENT THAN APPLICANT) Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. CONTRACTOR/ARCHITECT Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Please indicate below which Fencing and Yard sides of the building are jmpacted and provide documentation as applicable ptems Above Short Summary of Checked Field not completed. Please check to indicate the Field not completed. existing elements that will pe affected by the project Scope of Work: Describe he proposed project in detail, including all changes oi the building, site, or lot. include all features to be removed, replaced, altered, repaired, andlor added. Attach more sheets to provide all drawings and to describe all proposed, elements, materials and fheir specifications. Page 3 application. Install a wooden picket fence in the front yard and continue the fence into the back yard using black welded wire. Please complete the following checklist of required elements to complete your Attachments Checklist: In order to ensure completeness of your application, please complete the following checklist of required documentation. Any application without the necessary documentation and deemed incomplete by staff will not be accepted nor presented at the HPC hearing. Required Documentation: For All Applications (HPC-COA, ARC and EAR): Completed/ signed application form "Before" photos of existing conditions, should show the entire site, plan "After" obdrawigremdmgt: should indicate what the property Specifications and/or materials brochures describing in detail the manufacture, material, proportions and details of all new proposed elements of repair, replacement or new construction For New Construction, Addition or Demolition and elevation where the work is to be completed. will look like after proposed work is completed. Site plan, to scale. A site plan should include: property lines, lot dimensions, fence location, fence length and height, existing structure(s), existing or proposed porches, decks and outbuildings, right-ofway or access easements on the property (even if not in use), distance from property lines, and location of surrounding roads. Floor Plans (showing existing conditions, demolition and new construction) Dimensioned elevation drawings of all sides affected (including any Construction Details (including all materials specifications, ornamental For Fences, Porches and Site Improvements (decks, garages, demolition & new construction) elements, special features) sheds, pergolas) Site plan, to scale. A site plan should include: property lines, lot dimensions, fence location, fence length and height, existing structure(s), existing or proposed porches, decks and outbuildings, right-ofway or access easements on the property (even if not in use), distance from property lines, and location of surrounding roads. Drawingsphotographs of proposed alteration and modifications to site Material specifications including picture or product brochure of proposed product, as well as specification sheet for construction materials and pre-tabricated elements Solar Panels Roof plan, to scale, showing the location of all panels on the roof Photos of "before", and if possible "after" conditions viewed from street Elevations of locations with solar panels level or rights-of-way Signage Dimensioned drawing/rendering of proposed sign and placement on the Photos of streetscape, including surrounding signage if applicable. Modifications to mature trees and significant natural landscape Photos of existing conditions as they relate to the streetscape building features Jpload Documents Here Jpload HPC Document 1 Jpload HPC Document: 2 Jpload HPC Document 4 Survey_Fence.jpg Proposed fencing.docx Field not completed. Jpload HPC Document 3 Field not completed. Electronic Signature Agreement Electronic Signature pate Page 4 Internal Use Only Date Received Taken By Receipt # HPC Application # Meeting Date fice Use Only agree. Brian J Wlley 9/6/2024 Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Field not completed. Note: Make Checks Payable to the City of Cambridge Email not displaying correctly?) Viewi iti iny your browser. ja OAS in 110 Choptank Proposed Fencing Materials: 4'Wooden picket fencing in thet front, painted white (depicted inl black lines on the site plan) 4' Black welded wire with wooden posts (depictedi in blue lines on1 the site plan) Along the side adjacent to 112 Choptank: White picket fencing across thet front of the property to approximately 71 feet from the property line. Picket fence will continue towards the back of the property for 341 feet. Picket fence will terminate Welded wirei fencing will start at the corner 341 feet from thet front property line and: 21 feet fromi the house. Welded wire will extend 7f feet towards the property line with 112 Choptank before turning towards thel back of the property and running 1191 feet to terminate at the chain linki fence that runs against the side of the house. across the back lot line, 121 feet in from the property mark with 112 Choptank. Along the side adjacent to 108 Choptank: White picket fence will continue across the front of the house, turning 90 degrees towards the back of the property approximately 101 feet from the property corner. Picket fencing will continue 341 feet towards the back oft the property before turning 90 degrees towards the house and terminating Int the back oft the house, the welded wire fence will begin at the back corner of the house and continue at an angle towards the property line with 108 Choptank. Welded wirei fencing witl run approximately 971 feet towards the back of the property, terminating at the chain link fence alongt the against the house. back of the propervyaproamately 41 feet inside of the property corner. 110 Choptank. Ave Here is an example oft the welded wire fencelam planning on, Iwas noti intending to use top and bottom wooden rails, rather just with stained wooden posts so that iti is as minimally visually impactful as possible. 800 Glasgow Street Proposed scope ofwork: replacement of wooden windows with vinyl windows. 540. 800 Glasgow Street. Two story, three bay frame L-shaped house with a semi-hexagonal projecting bay. Modern exterior finishes. Ca. 1900. Contributing building. B. GWD 4.6.A. Historic windows and doors, including all significant related elements such as frames, sashes, shutters, hardware, glazing, sills, moldings, decorated jambs, sidelights and fanlights, and GWD 4.6.B. Existing historic windows and doors and their related elements with only minor deterio- ration shall be repaired where possible, rather than replaced, using appropriate wood epoxies and GWD 4.6.C. If deterioration is so advanced that a window or door must be replaced, it shall be re- placed in kind, matching the original design as closely as possible, including materials, number of lights, and other character defining features. Ifr replacement in kind is not technically or economically feasible, they shall be replaced in an appropriate substitute material, that matches the original in size, shape, texture, color, number of lights and panels, and other character defining features (see GWD 4.6.D. Prior to replacing windows original to the building, an in-depth survey of their condi- tions shall be conducted, their conditions documented, and HPC Staff shall confirm that the window! GWD 4.6.E. If existing deteriorated true divided light windows are replaced, the replacements shall be true divided light, or Simulated Divided Lights (SDL) windows, with appropriate muntins patterns. GWD 4.6.F. Window and door replacement shall fit the existing opening as closely as possible. Openings shall not be blocked down or enlarged to fit replacement windows or doors. Changes or reductions of window opening sizes on secondary and rear façades shall be subject to review by panels shall be retained and preserved ifi in good condition. patches. recommended list in Appendix B) or door must be replaced. Thermal glazed windows are permitted, Snap-on muntin grids are not allowed. HPC on a case-by case basis. Application to the Historic Preservation Commission HOC 202s-n HPC-24-11 Submitted On: Aug 17, 2024 Applicant Question Are you the property owner? Applicant & Joseph Kincaid 443-521-2661 @j incaide24@comcastnet Primary Location 800 GLASGOW: ST CAMBRIDGE, MD: 21613 Are you using a contractor for this project? No No Property (Land) Owner Information Estate of Marion L. Wheatley Jr. Name City Cambridge Zip Code 21613 Phone Number 4435212661 Street Address 5418 Whitehall Road State MD Email Address ncade24@comcasinet Project Information Building Type Residential Scope of Work Replacing five single windows, one double window and as side door Project Type (check all that apply) New Construction/Addition Façade Alterations andicapngPatoararng Replacement Windows true Please Specify Replacing side door Fence Signage Porches/Decks Other true Material Information Feature Affected Window and door type and style Existing Materials deteriorating windows and door Proposed Materials Ifnoti listed, please indicate here Image or link to proposed material required. Four single windows, one double window and a door Proposed Material Link (ifa applicable) Proposed Material Image (ifa applicable) Acknowledgement and Signature ihave reviewed, and understand the applicable HPC htps-pww.choosecambndgacomDocumentCentervlew: 2051Updated-Guidelines-Apnl-2023) for my project. Applicant/Owner Signature guidelines true 800Glasgow: St. Replaced Replaced vinyl window 3 - o S (9 E V - B de A - a 7 6l CAJ E 81624.1:12PM Invoioe# 11846501 * Invoice * ABC Supply Co. inc. Invoice# 11846501 ProVia THE PROFESBIONAL WAY Installation and After Sale Support If you need After-Sale support, whether it's installation instructions, registering your warranty, providing feedback, or Initlating a warranty daim or reorder, please dick the Installation Instructions & After Sale Support button for the appropriate line. Ify you need to reorder across multiple lines, dickhere. POI Number 11271759 SOLD-TO: ABCSUPPLY 00#743 ONE ABCPKWY STE#616 BELOIT, WI! 53511 608-368-2562 608-364-1980 FAX Line Product and Pricel Detalls 1 VINYLPRIME WINDOW 501 Double Hung Base Price Sub-Total Qty 1-- Margin: 30.00% Product Options- Aspect Window AP500 Series 501 - Double Hung White Opening Size: 30"x55" Unit Size: 29 1/2", x541 1/2" Constant Force Roller Tilt Balance System Snap-In Frame Sash Stops Double Profle! SAL Locks White' Vent Locks Whitel Hardware INNERGY Thermal Sash Reinforcement Roll Form Bottom Soreen (White) with BetterVue Screen Mesh SuIE Extender ComforTech DLA Single Strength Glass 3/4" IG1 Thickness Completed: 5- Production Complete Job Name CRESPIN ROOFING Status Invoiced SHIP-TO- 200509 ABCSUPPLY cO #560 15LEEST ANNAPOLIS, MD 21401 410-571-6720 410-571-6723 FAX sslmmakssekam User 1: Jb072217 Enter Date: 6/26/2024 Recelve Date: 7/2/2024 Ship Date: 7/18/2024 Est. Dropl Date: 7/18/2024 Involce Date: 7/19/2024 Order Type: Ship &I Invoice Truck: GALA7/18/24 Qty Ext.Cost Sell Price 5 1,099.31 1,570.40 219.86 219.86 314.08 314.08 Due to variances in color and manufacturing process, Image shown may varyf fromf final product. Refert to color samples when making color selection. hmps.lentiyinkprola.comlwtyinonapaspx70AdAINS-TISABS.T 1/3 8/16/24, 1:12PM Invoice# 11846501 2 VINYLI PRIME WINDOW! SET Factory Muling with 0° Mullion Margin: 30.00% Product Options- Aspect Window- AP500 Series White Opening Stze: 60"x x55" Two Across- Even Factory Mulled Mull Header Cover SIl Extender Glass- - AI Units: ComforTech DLA Single Strength Glass -3/4" IG1 Thickness Completed: 1- Production Complete 3 VINYLE PRIME WINDOW 501- Double! Hung Base Price Margin: 30.00% Product Options- Window Al. - 501 . Double Hung -Unit Size: 293 3/4"x541/2". Constant Forcel Roller TRE Balance System Snap-In Frame Sash Stops Double Profile SAL Locks White Vent Locks White Hardware INNERGY Thermal Sash Reinforcement Roll Form Bottom Sareen (White) with BetherVue: Screen Mesh Completed: 1-1 Production Complete VINYLI PRIME WINDOW 501 Doublel Hung Base Price Margin: 30.00% Product Options- Window A2- 501 Double Hung -Unit Size: 29: 3/4"x541 1/2" Constant Force Roller Tilt Balance System Snap-In Frame Sash Stops Double Profile SAL Locks White Vent Locks Whitel Hardware INNERGY Thermal Sash Reinforoement Roll! Form Bottom Sareen (White) with BetterVue! Soreen! Mesh Completed: 1- Production Complete Cost Subtotal: $1,572.54 Tax: $0.00 Total: $1,572.54 1 33.51 33.51 47.87 47.87 Duet to variances inc color and manulacturing process, Images shown may vary from final product. Refert to color samples when making color selection. 1 219.86 219.86 314.08 314.08 1 219.86 219.86 314.08 314.08 Sel! Price Subtotal: $2,246.43 Tax-6.0%: $134.79 Total: $2,381.22 Margin: 30.00% Total Openings: Total Unlts: 6 7 ProVla's' Terms a Conditions: Terms and Conditions of Sale mmpagrvwa.omders From Automation Automation Date Message Log (Sees snapshot.) (Sees snapshot.) 7/8/2024 12:22:30PM Add Comment 7220241:01:53PM Add Comment Ackowledgement emailed to enc.andersonçavocsuppy.com, kphbomnearowpy.om Adnowiedgement emalled to caneranearapewcom, sphbomearsppy.on palenylnspua.comesiynxonvap.g70ndanNo-1IB48SO1 2/3 8/17/24, 1:08F PM ProVial Energy Efficiencyl ENERGY STARB Programs (OProVia STAR Certific Fill in the drop down menus to find the NFRC -ENERGY STAR PRODUCTS- AS SMART CHOICE SAVE ENERGY-PROTECT OURI ENVIRONMENT ratings and ENERGY STAR qualifications ofa certain door or window. Or ify you have an Order Number, you can use that to ENERGY STAR and the EPA are committed toi improving manufacturer's products to ensure energy efficient products are ProVia is committed to helping you find energy-eficient doors and windows that meet ENERGY STAR requirements. lookup the values. U-F lect being produced. Product Line:Windows Series:Aspect Windows V Glass: ComforTech DLA Glass Strength: Single Strength V Model: Double Hung Grids:None Energy Performasee U-Factor (U.S/I-P): 0.27 Solar Heat Gain Coefficient 0.28 Visible Transmittance: 0.52 Condensation Resistance: 60.00 (SHGC): Air Infiltration: 0.05 cfm/A2 U-Factor-Thel insulating value ofe an entire window system. Lower numbers reflect betteri insulating value. PEhmepDAacmenwprsytareayprstaisw 6/10