CITY OF ANNA MARIA P.O. Box 779, 10005 Gulf Drive, Annal Maria, FL 34216 Phone (941) 708-61301 Fax (941)708-6134 APRIL26, 2022, AT 10:00 A.M. CITY HISTORIC PRESERVATION BOARD MEETING CITY HALL COMMISSION CHAMBERS Optional Attendance by' Telecommunications Media  AGENDA  Dial in by using your phone. United States: 929-205-6099 Access Code: 856-9556-7017  *Outo ofc courtesy for others, please mute your phone when not speaking  Pledge of Conduct: We may disagree, but we will be respectful of one another. We will direct all comments to the  issues. We will avoid personal attacks. CALLTO ORDER PLEDGE: TOTHEI FLAG ROLL CALL  REGULAR MEETING  General Public Comment regarding non-agenda items and items not scheduled for future agendas will be taken at the beginning oft the meeting with al limitation of three minutes. The Board's intenti is that General Public comment is to be used for thej public toi inform thel Historic Preservation Board ofnewi issues within the City. Public Comment: regarding  agenda items will be taken with each agenda item with al limitation ofthree minutes.  1. General Public Comment 3. Board Member) Discussion 4. Set Date and' Time ofNext Board Meeting 5. Approval ofl Meeting Minutes: April 7,2022  2. Public Hearing - Certificate ofl Designation ofHistoric Structure  302 Gulf Boulevard, Owner Dominique Hostetler  Press Comment Adjournment  6 (FSS 286.26) IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE AMERICANS WITHI DISABILITIES ACT AND FLORIDA STATE: STATUTES, PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES NEEDING SPECIAL ASSISTANCE1 TOPARTICIPATE INT THIS PROCEEDING SHOULD CONTACTTHE CITY CLERK FOR ASSISTANCE. ATLEAST THREE BUSINESS DAYS PRIOR TO1 THE MEETING (941) 708-6130. SHOULD ANY INTERESTED PARTY SEEK TO APPEAL ANY DECISION MADE WITH RESPECT TO ANY MATTER CONSIDERED AT THIS MEETING, THEY WILL NEED TO ENSURE THAT AV VERBATIM RECORD OF1 THE PROCEEDINGS BE MADE, WHICH RECORD INCLUDES THE TESTIMONY. AND EVIDENCE UPON WHICH THE  APPEAL IST TO BE BASED.    City of Anna Maria, FLORIDA Historic Preservation Board Application for Designation of Historic Property  Return to: City Hall 10005 Gulf Dr. Annal Maria, FL34216  Property Owner(s): Name: HanykDohinique HoskcHer Address: 575 N.Hy 83 City:, HarHand Phone: Applicant: Name: Same, Address: City: Phone: Agent (if applicable): Name: Address: City: Phone: General Information: PropertyLocation ora address:  Emall: Zip: Cell: Email: Zip: Cell: Email: Zip: Cell:  gehaseler@mac.com)  "WI Fax:  53029 708-206-2851  State: Fax:  MA  State: Fax:  Anna Maria Tax Parcell ID:  302 Gulf BIVO,FL 34216 Legal Description (attach additionalsheetsa asr necessary):, * LoT I8,BLOCK 32/Ama, Maria Bech BECORDED IN PLAT, Book 1 PAGE 216,Public Recrds.Manatelky Current Use of Properfy: Vacation Rental Date of Constructlon/Deveopment: 1921  7029700007 Current Designation ofP Property: Land Use:  Residential  Asp property within Historic District? YES NO_ *T3HS,R/6E,S/B  Historic Designation Requested: Site D Archeological Site D District D  Building,  Structure/D    Prior to the designation of any historic resource, an application for a certificate of designation shall be submitted to the historic preservation board. This application shall  contain, as a minimum, the following information: For individual historic buildings, structures and objects: defining features, accompanied by photographs.  a. A physical description of the building, structure or object and its character- The home can be described as a frame vernacular style with Victorian and Craftsman- style elements including but not limited to; broad gable roof with overhanging eaves, Upon review of historic photos of the structure, the porch appears to be an afterthought and the Victorian" gingerbread could be considered a bit out of character with the rest of SW/FRONT PORCH: incised front porch with screen enclosure. The original incised porch was full-width across the facade, which was a typical feature of Anna Maria's earliest cottages, many of which were built for the Anna Maria Beach Co. Although unverified, this home was most likely designed and built by Mitch Davis and the Anna Maria Beach Company. Mitch Davis was also the City's first Mayor. b. A description of the existing condition of the building, structure or object, including any potential threats or other circumstances that may affect the  exposed rafters, triangular knee braces, wood shingle wall cladding  the structure.  integrity of the building, structure or object.  Overall, the building is in good condition. There is cloth wiring throughout the home, the windows are all failing and there is some termite damage. The home also lacks any Due to the fact the building fronts on the Gulf of Mexico there is always a potential threat C. A statement of the historical, architectural or other significance of the building, structure or object as defined by the criteria for designation established by this This C.1913 Frame Vernacular home has been identified as being part of an iconic group of early 1910s homes fronting beach on Gulf Blvd; originally part of the "Red Houses" or "Gulf Beach Cottages". Itis believed that the small cottages were built for the (4) four daughters of a citrus baron. All four homes are painted different colors, reminiscent ofthe "painted lady" style; this one being blue. The home has a wide screened porch along the Itf features simple form, broad gable roof with overhanging eaves, incised porch, and a half-story in the attic. It was built within the period of significance, retains historic integrity  insulation. The owner plans to address these issues soon.  ofi flooding or wind damage.  chapter.  front facade.  and is considered a contributing resource to the district.    As noted above, this home was most likely designed and built by Mitch Davis and the Anna Maria Beach Company. Mitch Davis was also the City's first Mayor. d. A statement of rehabilitative or adaptive use proposals, if applicable. Not Applicable. There are no rehabilitative or adaptive use proposals associated with this e. A location map showing zoning and other appropriate land use information and Please see attached. Legal Description: LOT 18 BLK: 32 ANNA MARIA BEACH f.7 The name of the building, structure or object, and the Florida Master. Site File  request.  a legal description of the property.  P#70297.00007 number, if applicable. 308 Gulf Boulevard  Florida Master Site File Number: MA02276 g. The name and address of the property owner.  Dominique & Harry Hostetler 302 Gulf Boulevard Anna Maria, FL 34216  h.Any other appropriate information requested by the board.  No additional information requested to date.    AERIAL VIEW  PROPERTY. ADDRESS: 302 GULFBOULEVARD, ANNA MARIA, FLORIDA 34216  LEGEND  LEGAL DESCRIPTION: LOTI 18, BLOCK32, ANNA MARIAL BEACH, ACCORDING: 7O7 THE MAPORI PLAT THEREOF ASI RECORDEDI INI PLAT BOOK. 1, PAGE216, PUBLICI RECORDS OFA MANATEE COUNTY FLORIDA. CERTIFIED TO: HAREYHOSTETIERO DOMINIQUE HOSTETLER/ INDS SARFRAZS KELLY FIELDDATE: 12/2/2021 BERLINP PATTEN EBLING PLIC OLD! APPROVEDBY: 1S COMPANY COMPANY ITSS SUCCESSORSA ANDIOR ASSIGNS: AS7 THEIR INTERESTEMAYAPPEAR DRAWNDATE: 12/09/21 FRSTCHOICESURVAYING INC. P.O.. BOX470978, LAKEMONROE, FL32747 407.951.3425 (Office); 407.520.5453 (Fax); LB# #7564 WWPRSTCHOICESURVEYING.COMA  NDDISK PREVENTER WELL LINE ENT FENCE  CLIENTNO: JOBNO: 62565 DRAWNBY: MG.  BANK TRUST CHECKEDBY: H.P  AERIAL PROVIDEDI ISFOR VIEWINGG ONLY AERIAL ISNOTT TOSCALE ORDEREDBY:    BOUNDARY SURVEY  LOT8 BLOCK 32   IRON ROD #7564  (PI) o  72  LOT17 BLOCK 32  NOTE: P)-PLAT M)-MEASURED (C)- CALCULATED AR CONDITIONER PAD SURVEYORS NOTE: GULF SETE BACK. PER CTY ND IS NO COCLISA APPROXIMATELY 162+/ FROM OUR PROPERTY NE  - &  LINE TABLE N 45/00'00" E(C) 100.00' (P) N 44'42'59" E 100.03' (M) N 45'00'00" w(c) 57.50' (P) N 44'52'59" w 54.85' (M) N 45'00'00" w(c) 57.50' (P) N 45'07'48" w 59.95' (M) N 45'00'00" w(c) 57.50' (P)  PROPERTY. ADDRESS: 302 GULFBOULEVARD, ANNA. MARIA, FLORIDA 34216  LEGEND VUMENT  LEGAL DESCRIPTION: LOT18, BLOCK32, ANNA MARIAE BEACH, ACCORDINGTO THEA MAP ORP PLAT7 THEREOF AS RECORDEDI INI PLATBOOKI 1, PAGE 216, PUBLICK RECORDS OFA MANATEE COUNTY FLORIDA. CERTIFIED TO: CLIENTNO: HARRY HOSTETLERCI DOMINIQUE JOBNO: 62565 HOSTETLERA INDS SARFRAZS SIDHUC KELLY FIELDDATE: 12/2/2021 SIDHU: BERLINP PATTEN EBLING, PLLG OLD REPUBLIC NATIONAL TITLE APPROVEDBY: 1S COMPANY FIRSTICITIZENS BANK d7 TRUST CHECKEDBY: HP COMPANY ASSIGNS: AS7 7SS THEIRI SUCCESSORSA INTERESTSMAYA APPEAR DRAWNBY: MG DRAWNDATE: 12/09/21 CERTFYT TIATT TIIFS SIRVTYOFTIRIErON/ DESCA MYDIRIKTS SI:PERVISIANA ANDA TI STANDARDOFA SETIPRTADYT TE FLORIDA MARDOT CSPXARXASTN TROIGI -17.051A FLORIDAA ADMINSINS VECUDEASDNT: 472.027, - CATNAN S141 RYOOANINSAL. ) VONRDEFLS 32717 ORAASAVE NOT VALIDWITHOUT: SIGNATUREA ANDRAISEDSEALORE DATESIGNED: 12/09/21  CHO  POINTS OFI INTEREST: GARAGEI ISE ENCROACHING  GRAPHIC SCALE: I"=30 SURVEYOR'S NOTES:  FLOODZONE (FOR ATIONAL PURPOSESONLY) BJECT PERTY SHOWNI HEREON TOBEL MAPA THIS THE HE 10C AL  SEAL  NFORM    k        Page 1 Original DUpdate  HISTORICALSTRUCTURE FORM Site#8 MA02276  FLORIDA MASTER SITEFILE Version 5.0 3/19 Shaded Fieldsr representt ther minimuma acceptable leveld of documentation. Consult the Guide toH Historical Structure Formsf for detailedi instructions.  Field Date 1-10-2022 Form! Date 1-28-2022 Recorder#  MM  Sitel Name(s) (addressi ifnone). 302 Gulf Boulevard  Multiple Listing (DHR only) Survey#( (DHRonly).  Survey Project Name City of Anna Maria Historic Resources Survey National Register Category (please check one) building structure Ddistrict [site DJobject  Ownership: Eprivate-profit EIprivate-nonprofit Bprivate-individual privale-nonspedific Ecity DJcounty [state Dfederal Native American [foreign DJunknown  LOCATION& MAPPING  Street! Number Direction Street! Name  Streetl Type Boulevard  SuffxD Direction  Address: 302 Cross Streets (nearest /between). USGS7.5N Mapl Name ANNA MARIA TaxF Parcel #. 7029700007 Subdivision Name_ ANNA MARIA BEACH PB1/216 UTM Coordinates: Zone 016 017 Easting! Other Coordinates: X: Name of Public Tract (e.g. park).  Gulf  USGSI Date, 2021 Plat or Other Map  City Town (within3miles) City of Anna Maria In City! Limits? lyes Dno Dunknown County Manatee Township. 34S Range. 16E Section. 18 1 section: DNW DSW DSE DNE Irregular-name:  Landgrant. Block Coordinate System & Datum  32  Lot  18  Northing! HISTORY  Y:  Construction Year 1913 Lapproximately lyear listed ore earlier Dlyear listed or later Original Use Private Residence louse/Cottage/Ca From (year): 1913 To( (year) Current Use Private Residence louse/Cottage/Ca From (year)  To/year) 2022 To( (year): 2022  Other Use Vacation Rental Beach House Moves: Dlyes no DJunknown Date:. Alterations: Xlyes Dno Junknown Date: Additions: lyes Dno DJunknown Date: Architect (lastr namef first): Ownership History (especiallyo original owner, dates, profession, etc.) Martin  From (year) Original address_  Nature front porch partially enclosed Nature small rear addition  Builder (lastr namef first): Davis, Mitch (unverified)  1964:Address not listed (beach erosion caused streets to be reconfigured); 1972:Robert B.  Ist the Resource Affected! bya a Local Preservation Ordinance? Dlyes no Dunknown Describe.  DDSCRIPTION Exterior Plan Square 2. 2.  Style Frame Vernacular Exterior Fabric(s) 1.Shingles-wood Roof Type(s) 1.Gable Roof Material(s) 1.Sheet metal:standing seam 2. Roof secondary strucs. (dormers etc.)1., Windows (types, materials, etc.)  Number of Stories 1.5  3., 3.. 3., 2..  DHS, wood,grouped0).aA, DHS,wood,1/1; DHS,wood,paired,1A rafters, triangular knee braces, wood shingle wall cladding Ancillary Features/Oulbuidings: (record outbuildings, majorl landscape features; use continuation: sheeti ifneeded.)  Distinguishing Architectural Features (exterior ori interior ornaments)  Victorian and Craftsman-style elements: broad gable roof with overhanging eaves, exposed part of an iconic group of early 1910s homes fronting beach on Gulf Blvd; originally part of  the "Red Houses" or "Gulf Beach Cottages"  DHRI USE ONLY  OFFICIAL EVALUATION Elyes Dno  DHR USE ONLY  NRI List Date  SHPO- Appearst tor meet criteriai for NRI listing: Dyes Eno Dinsufficient info Date_  Init.  KEEPER. Determined eligible:  Date  DJOwner Objection NR Criteriat for Evaluation: Da Db Dc Dd (see National Register Bulletin 15,p.2) HR6E046R0319, effective 05/2016 Floridal Master Site Filel /Div. ofHistoricalF Resourcesl /R. A.G Gray Bldgl 500SB Bronough St., Tallahassee, FL 32399-0250  Rule 1A-46.001,FA.C.  Phone 850.245.64401 /Fax 850.245.6439/E-mail Siefle@dosmylonda.com:    Page 2  HISTORICALSTRUCTURE FORM DESCRIPTION (continued)  Sitet #8 MA02276  Chimney: No. 0 Chimney Material(s): 1. Structural System(s): 1. Wood frame Foundation Type(s): 1. Piers Foundation Material(s): 1. Obscured Main Entrance (styisticd details) Screen door and wood steps Porch Descriptions (types, locations, rooft types, etc.)  2. chimney capped  2. 2., 2.  3.  SW/FRONT PORCH: incised front porch with screen enclosure. The original incised porch was full-width across the facade, which was a typical feature of Anna Maria's earliest cottages, This C.1913 Frame Vernacular home is part of an iconic group of beach cottages built on the Gulf for the Anna Maria Beach Co. It features simple form, broad gable roof with overhanging  many of which were built for the Anna Maria Beach Co. Condition (overall resource condition): excellent [good [fair deteriorated Druinous eaves, incised porch, and a half-story in the attic.  Narrative Description of Resource Archaeological Remains  LICheckArchaedlogial Form Completed [Sanborn maps [Publicl Lands Survey (DEP) DJHABS/HAER record search  RESEARCH METHODS: (adlectallhatapply,  IFMSF records search (sites/surveys) IFL State Archives/photo collection property appraiser /taxr records cultural resource survey (CRAS) DJother methods (describe). Library_Digital Collection  library research city directory newspaper files historic photos  building permits Eneighbori interview Dinterior inspection  Joccupantlowner interview plat maps  Bibliographic References (give FMSF manusaurptflfrelevan!, use continuation: sheetifneeded)  Historic Photos: Anna Maria Island Historical Museum Archives, and Manatee County Public  OPINIONI OF RESOURCDSIGNIFICANCD  Appears tor meet the criteria forl National Register listing individually? Explanation of Evaluation (required, whethers significant or not; uses separate sheetifneeded)  [lyes Dno insufficienti information  Appears to meet the criteria for National Register listing as part ofa a district? lyes Dno Dinsufficienti information This resource is located in the NR-eligible Gulf Boulevard Historic District and Frame Vernacular Thematic District. It was built within the period of significance, retains historic Area(s) of Historical Significance (see National Register Bulletin1 15,p.8forc categories: e.g." 'architecture", "ethnich heritage", "community planning8 & development", etc.)  integrity and is considered a contributing resource to the district.  1.Architecture  3.Tourism  5.. 6..  2. Community planning & developm 4.  DOCUMIENTATION V Maintaining organization File ora accession #s Maintaining organization File ora accession #'s Affiliation  Accessible Documentation Not Filed with the Site File including fieldr notes, analysis notes, photos, plans ando otheri important documents  Documentt type Document description Documentt type Document description  V  RECORDER INFORMATION  Recorder Name Megan Mclaughlin, AICP, Plusurbia  Recorder Contact Information 1385 Coral Way #401 Miami, FL 33145 / 305-444-4850 / meganeplusurbia.com  adess/phone/baxlemal, Required Attachments  USGS 7.5' MAP WITH STRUCTURE LOCATION CLEARLY INDICATED 2 LARGE SCALE STREET, PLAT ORI PARCEL MAP (available from mostp properlya appraisery webs sites) When submitting ani image, itl must bei includedi in digital ANDI hard copyf format (plainp paper grayscalea acceptable).  PHOTO OF MAIN FACADE, DIGITAL IMAGE FILE Digitali image must be atl least 1600x1 1200 pixels, 24-bit color, jpeg or tiff.        Huy ch ettagen 191  KEEEND ON BACK OF SNAPSHoT  WINTER 1916  ANwp MARIA BEACH, FLoRiDA "Ju are Zku mly huday fou milis NOTE: Roct CORNER of BATHHOUSE Shows GT lefT SIDE of PieTURE BEACH END oS spkin9  'AVE    0f