TROY OHIO  AGENDA - TROY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING WEDNESDAY, MAY 22, 2024, 3:30 P.M. CITY HALL, COUNCIL CHAMBERS 1. Roll Call 2. Minutes - May 8, 2024  3. Historic District Application - Certificate of Appropriateness, new awning and awning sign for 75.  Market Street, Creative Countertops. Commission to make decision  Owner- Applicant 4. Other 5. Adjourn  Jay Harris Creative Countertops  Next Meeting - June 12, 2024  Note to Commission members: If you will not be attending, please email or call Sue.    Aregular meeting of the Troy Planning Commission was heldi in Council Chambers, City Hall,  May8, 2024 Wednesday, May 8, 2024, at 3:30 p.m. with Westmeyer, Oda and Titterington; April 24, 2024, meeting were OHI form describes this structure adjacent building on Tricor Black (SW 6258), and the 2.6 states: Concentration of Historically painted surfaces should asl larger Queen Annes styles, mayi incorporate feels that the request meets as the paint colors comply with Design Manual Section 2.6  Chairman James McGarry presiding. ATTENDING: Development Staff- - R. Long; and Development Director Davis.  Members - McGary, Emerick, Ehrlich, Wolke,  APPROVAL OF MINUTES: Upon motion of Mr. Emerick, seconded by Mr. Westmeyer, the minutes of HISTORIC DISTRICT APPLICATION. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS. 109 W. WATER ST.  approved by unanimous voice vote.  ANNELISE KIMMEL; APPLICANT- RANDY KIMMEL. Staff reported: zoningi is B-3, Central Business District; PAINT COLORS: OWNER-  as old veracular structure with simple frame voids; the siding is 6 course. American bond February 22, 2023; application is to paint the main building color Iron Ore (SW 7069); accent colors will be window trim will be Extra White (SW7 7006); proposed paint colors will complement the the Extra White (SW 7006) and the window and door trim is Black of similar colors on the same block should be avoided. Historically Unpainted surfaces should remain painted. Simpler buildings should have a simple color scheme. More omate structures, such theser requirements oft the Design Manual and recommends approval oft the application  the Eastlake door and 1/1 double hung windows;  whichi indicates antiquity; contributing features include adjoining building as the main body color oft that building is  Planning Commission approved the paint and exterior alterations of the  Night (SW 6993); Design Manual Section  not be painted.  three or more colors. In all circumstances, and the alterations do not cover the  avoid bright and obtrusive colors, such as neon or day-glow hues." Staff  contributing features noted ont the OHI Form.  Discussion. Mr. Titterington asked whati is beingr repainted andi itv was statedi itv willl bei the entire building. Ar motion was made by Mayor Oda, seconded by Mr. Westmeyer, that the Troy Planning Commission  Application, Certificate of Appropriateness for 109V W. Water Street as submitted, based ont the exact colors of approves the Historic District  accent colors will be Tricom Black (SW 6258) and the window trim Extra White  main building Iron Ore (SW 7069),  of staff that the paint colors Form.  (SW 7006) as stated in the application, and based on the findings MOTION ADOPTED BY UNANIMOUS ROLL CALL  comply with Design Manual Section 2.6 and the alterations do not cover the contributing features  noted on the OHI standards VOTE do not require by the City; and by Mr. Titterington, and  PAINTED PIANO PROGRAM IN THE HISTORIC DISTRICT JUNE - AUGUST. Staff noted the approval as the placement of the pianos is temporary, and this is provided as information. The and'  design  public art program of Painted Pianos in the downtown the months of this program has been enjoyed by the publici inj priory years. approved by unanimous voice vote.  City Troy Main Street again plan to have the  pianos will be  June - August; the program will promote visual arts and music; some oft the  painted to help celebrated the 100" Anniversary of The Troy Foundation; general locations have been determined There being no further business, the meeting adjoumed at 3:39 p.m. upon motion of Mrs. Ehrlich, seconded  Respectfully: submitted,  Chairman Secretary        Russell Long Zoning Inspector  TROY DEVELOPMENT DIPARTMENT  Russell.long@troyohio.gov  MEMORANDUM  TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: BACKGROUND: Business District.  City of Troy Planning Commission Members Russell Long, Zoning Inspector May 22, 2024  Historic Review - 7S. Market St. - New Awning and Awning Sign  The applicant and tenant, Creative Countertops, at 7 South Market St, has requested the Planning Commissiont to consider the installation ofar new awningand: sign. The property is located int the B-3 Central The OHI form lists this as a three-story, brick building built in 1886. It lists the style as High Victorian Italianate with circular windows and pracketed box cornice. Contributing feature include: 1/1 double hung  windows, bracket box cornice, and paneled frieze.  DISCUSSION:  The proposed awning will be composed of fabric on a metal frame mounted to the building using the existing brackets and hardware. The new awning will measure 41 feet by 15 feet and be black in color. This The proposed signage will be printed on the new awning. The lettering and Logo will be centered on the awning and will be Gold and White in color. The sign area will be 3 feet by 71 feet totaling 21 square feet.  new awning will bé the exact size and color as the current awning.  STAFF ANALYSIS:  The design manual states the following regarding awnings:  3.11 Awnings and Canopies  A. Fabric awnings should have a matte rather than a glossy surface. C. Atraditional flat, sloped awning design should be used. using no more than two colors is preferred.  B. Each window or door should have its own awning, rather than a single full-width awning covering D. Awning color(s) should complement the building and be compatible with historically appropriate colors used on the building but avoid overly ornate patterns and too many colors. A: simple pattern The proposed awning meets this requirement. The awning is black fabric and not a glossy surface. The  an entire façade.  awning is also traditional and flat and avoids using overly ornate patterns or styles.  100 South Market Street, Troy, OH 45373-7303    RussellLong Zoning Inspector  TROY DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT  Russell.long@troyohio.gov  5.6 Awning Signs A. Awning sign designs should be coordinated with the architectural character of the storefront. The use of stripes and scalloped edges should be minimized unless there is substantial The sign complies with this requirement. The sign is simple in design, and avoids scalloped edges.  evidence that the detail is historically appropriate.  RECOMMENDATION:  Staff recommends approval of the proposed awning and sign based on the following:  The alteration does not cover or otherwise negatively affect the contributing features as referenced The proposed alterations and signage are in line with the Design Manual and the City of Troy Sign  on the OHI form. Code.  Similar awnings and signage currently exist within the Historic District.  100 South Market Street, Troy, OH 45373-7303    7-13 5 pankal  Ohio Historic Presurvation Ufice Ohio Historical Center Columbus, Ohio 43211  OHIO HISTORIC INVENTORY  1NOATA 230 G 0928-00057N ounty Miami 3. Location of Negatives Regional Office 5HA 6. Specific Location $M EP, (S. Main  4. Present Name(s) 5. Other Name(s)  1886 Building 16. Thematic Category  28. No. of Stories 3 Basement? 29. 30. Foundation Material 31. Wall Construction brick 32. Roof Type & Material 33. No. of Bays Front 34. Wal! Treatment 35. Plan Shapepectangular (Explain in #42) 37. Condition Interlor_ Exterior_ excellent Yes 8 38. Preservation No D Underway? 39. Endangered? ByWhat? 40. Visible Publlc Road? from 41. Distance from and Frontage on Road Street front 45' wide  C  1886  Street, 75 meters  Yes 0 NoD  from Public Square, East- 17. Date(s) or Period  side.  7. City or Town #fRural, Township & Vicinity 18. Style or Design  Tpoyy 8. Site" Plan with North Arrow N 3.36, nia  High Victorain Italianate 19. Architect or Engineer 20. Contractor or Builder 21. Original Use, If apparent commercial 22. Present Use commercial 23.Ownership 24. Owner's Name & Address, if known 25. Opent to  Side  Public D 36. Changes Private B  Addition a Altered b Moved D  9. Coordinates Troy Lat. U.T.M. Reference Zone  Long.  16 73/8l5'glo WW35580  Easting Site D Bullding 0 11.OnN National Yes 6 12.1slt Register? No D 13. Part of Estab. Yes B 14. District Yes a Hist. Dist.? No 0 15. Name of Established District Trov Public Square Historic Dist. 42. Further Description of Important Features  Northing  Yes LB No 0 Yes D NoB Yes9 Noo  Structure D Public?  Object D 26. Local Contact Person or Organization Yes a Troy Historical Society Eligible? No a 27. Other Surveys In Which Included  Potent"l? NoO  Store fronts butchered. Central bay and terminals set off by stylized pilasters. Windows are 1/1 D.H.S. with continuous segmental hood moulds. Third range slight circular windows, bracketed box cornice  central peak  43. History and Significance  An excellent high Victorian Italianate facade.  44. Description of Environment and Outbuildings  In downtown Troy 45. Sources of Information  46. Prepared by L.S. Gannon, Jr. 47. RégiSHPoffice 5HA 48. Date 49. Revision Date(s) 7/741    TROY DIVELOFMENT DEPARTMENT  Troy Damppaniss  E  CyOFTROY PLANNING COMMISSION APPLICATION FORH HISTORICAL TROYARCHTECTURAL DISTRICT  Date 5:724  Applicant_ Creative Countrtops Telephonel No. 937:540:9460  Owner of Properyay Harvis  Hast the Owner been Notified?. Y5  Address off Project 7 Sukh Market Shrcct Contact Address (if different than Project Address) Application for renovation toi include thei following:  Name of Architect/Engineer and/or Contractor_ Flawless Slyns  Alteration Construction Moving ABuilding Painting  Repair  Demolish- Principal Structure Demolish Accessory! Structure Xother Replace Auminy  Will the workr require use oft the public right of way? (Blocking ofs sidewalk, parking spaces, etc?) Yes No  "Ifyes, a use of public spaçe application is required ONE (1) COPY OF INFORMATION" TO BE SUPPLIEDI BY APPLICANT: (b) Description of proposed use,i if different than existing use.  (a) Site Plan drawni to scale shall be provided showing structure inc question & its relationship to adjacent structures.  (c) Plans illustrating thep proposed structural. or exterior changes, including changes m parking faciities, landscaping, screening, fences,  signs and other rélevant structurés and1 fixtures, and relationshipt to surrounding structures. (d) Description and: samples ofr matérials propased tot be used in the project. (E) Any other photographs or llustrative visual aids andlor materials relevant to the project.  (e) Paint samples for painting applications. (h) Application fee: $25.00  (g) A written letter from. the owner acknowedging the application, or a printed signature fromt the properly owner on thisi form. *Thel Planning Commission meets ont the second and fourth Wednesday ofe every month, Completed applications are due a minimum  oft two weeks priort to the requested meeting date.  OFFICEUSEONLY DATE FILED: CASES DATEOEMEETNG:  SIGNATUREOFAPUCAMT: ##  PRINTEDNAME OF PROPERTY OWNER: sy HARes  102SouthMarket: Street, Troy, OH 45373-7303  ddz R YORES    % CAMBRIA   CAMBRIA  EXISTINGAWNING  PROPOSED NEW AWNING  Existing Awningis 18'x6'  New awning will be black and remain the same size Lettering will be gold as in the picture. Lettering size should be no greater than 3'x7'