OF IR,  MINUTES CITY COUNCIL REGULAR MEETING January 9, 2024 City Council Chamber 1 Civic Center Plaza Irvine, CA 92606  CALL TO ORDER  The regular meeting oft the Irvine City Council was called to order at 4:07 p.m. on January 9, 2024, in the City Council Chamber, Irvine Civic Center, 1 Civic Center Plaza, Irvine,  California; Mayor Khan presiding.  ROLL CALL  Present: 5 Councilmember:  Mike Carroll* Tammy Kim Kathleen Treseder Larry Agran Farrah N. Khan  Councimember: Councimember: Vice Mayor: Mayor:  *viai teleconference  Following roll call, Councimember Carroll announced that he would be participating virtually in the meeting due to a contagious illness. He also noted that he was required to disclose whether any individuals 18 years of age or older were present with him in the room and his relationship to those individuals as required by Assembly Bill 2449, and confirmed that no individuals 18 years of age or older were present with him in the room  during the meeting.    City Council Minutes 1.  January 9.2024  CLOSED SESSION  City Attorney Melching announced the following Closed Session items:  1.1  CONFERENCE WITH REAL PROPERTY NEGOTIATORS (Government Code $ 54956.8) - Property: 8000 Great Park Blvd, Irvine, CA 92618; Agency Negotiators: Oliver Chi, City Manager; Pete Carmichael, Assistant City Manager; Jeffrey Melching, City Attorney; Negotiating Parties: City of Irvine; Ellen Pais, Executive Director, Pretend City Children's Museum; Under Negotiation: CONFERENCE WITH REAL PROPERTY NEGOTIATORS (Government Code S 54956.8) - Property: 8000 Great Park Blvd, Irvine, CA 92618; Agency Negotiators: Oliver Chi, City Manager; Pete Carmichael, Assistant City Manager; Jeffrey Melching, City Attorney; Negotiating Parties: City of Irvine; Douglas Freeman, Chief Executive Officer, OC Music and Dance: Under Negotiation: CONFERENCE WITH REAL PROPERTY NEGOTIATORS (Government Code $ 54956.8) - Property: 8000 Great Park Blvd, Irvine, CA 92618; Agency Negotiators: Oliver Chi, City Manager; Pete Carmichael, Assistant City Manager; Jeffrey Melching, City Attorney; Negotiating Parties: City of Irvine; Michael Aguilar, Chief Foundation/Flylng Leathernecks Aviation Museum; Under  Price and Terms of Payment  1.2  Price and Terms of Payment  1.3  Executive  Officer,  Flying  Leathernecks  Historical  Negotiation: Price and Terms of Payment There were no requests to speak.  RECESS  Mayor Khan recessed the City Council meeting to Closed Session at 4:13 p.m.  RECONVENE TO THE CITY COUNCIL MEETING  Mayor Khan reconvened the City Council meeting at 5:10 p.m. City Attorney Melching, on behalf of the City Council, announced that no reportable action was taken in Closed  Session.  PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE  Councimember Treseder led the Pledge of Allegiance.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  2    City Council Minutes INVOCATION  January 9. 2024  Imam-in-Training Sayed Adil, accompanied by Shaykh Mustafa Umar from the Islamic  Center of Irvine, provided the invocation.  2.  PRESENTATIONS 2.1  Proclaim January 13, 2024, as "Korean American Day"  Mayor Khan introduced Charles Kim, District Representative on behalf of California State Senator Dave Min, and representatives from several Korean American organizations, and presented a proclamation recognizing January 13, 2024, as "Korean American Day." Proclaim January 15, 2024, as "Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. Day" Mayor Khan introduced Amil Aaron, Chair of the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Committee, and representatives from other organizations, and presented a proclamation recognizing January 15, 2024, as "Dr. Martin  2.2  Luther King, Jr. Day."  Following presentations, Mayor Khan reordered the agenda to consider the City Manager's Report, Announcements/Committee Reports/Council Reports, and Additions and Deletions prior to public comments on non-agendized items. She also announced that only thirty minutes of public comments on non-agendized items would be taken initially, and that all other public comments for non-agendized items would be taken  following consideration of all agendized items. CITY MANAGER'S REPORT  City Manager Chi provided a brief overview related to an ethics complaint received on December 22, 2023 related to statements made by Mayor Khan and Vice Mayor Agran regarding the situation ini the Middle East, use ofCity resources specific to the deployment of members of the Irvine Police Department at the December 12 meeting, and consideration of nonmunicipal matters. City Attorney Melching also provided a brief overview of the investigative process and noting findings of no wrongdoing and the basis  for that finding.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  3    City Council Minutes  January 9. 2024  ANNOUNCEMENTS/COMMITTEE REPORTSICOUNCIL REPORTS  Mayor Khan  Mayor Khan expressed appreciation to Joy Sun, Irvine resident and high school student, for her founding of the Change into Change Foundation, a certified Irvine Green Business, which offers a t-shirt with interchangeable designs and allows individuals to be environmentaly sustainable with their clothes while highlighting the designs. Ms. Sun is one of a few high school students in Irvine to achieve that Last month, Mayor Khan hosted a Small Business Town Hall with Small Business Administration (SBA) Deputy Administrator Dilawar Syed that included over 100 attendees who learned about SBA's resources and grant opportunities. SBA lent $1.2 billion in Orange County with additional funding anticipated sometime this year. The City will host additional follow up events to ensure that its businesses The City is partnering with Switch is On and Southern California Edison to provide af free Electrification 101 Workshop from 6 to 8 p.m. on Wednesday, January 17, at City Hall. Attendees will hear testimonials from residents and learn: 1) what it means to transition from gas to electric-powered appliances; 2) how to make energy-efficient upgrades that save both energy and money; and 3) what federal, state, and local rebates are available. The event includes an expo from 7t to 8 p.m. that allows members of the public to connect with local organizations, contractors to learn more about joining the City's path to achieving its climate goals, and customers to learn how to save money and energy by electrifying. To sign up, visit The Irvine Animal Care Center (IACC) will conclude its Holiday Donation Drive on Monday, January 15, which allows IACC to continue its lifesaving work through the Enhanced Care, Third Chance for Pets, and Foster Care programs. Thanks to community support, IACC has found homes for more than 13,750 animals through the Third Chance for Pets program since itl began in 1999. Community support also enabled IACC to provide enhanced care treatment as well as quality care recovery for hundreds of underage, ill, or recuperating animals in the Foster Care program last year. To support the donation drive, visit rvineanimals.org/nolidaydrive.  certification. To learn more, visit hangenoChange.com.  connect with needed resources and support.  yourirvine.org.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  4    City Council Minutes Councilmember Kim  January 9. 2024  The Orange County Fire Authority (OCFA) is equipped to tackle the most challenging fires and protect our open space. The OCFA's Quick Reaction Force has three of the world's largest firefighting helicopters capable of dropping 3,000 gallons of water. In addition, OCFA is upgrading its firefighting infrastructure with the introduction of the HeloPod near Ortega Highway, which will significantly improve the helicopters' access to water during wildfires in and around Orange County, including Irvine. Councilmember Kim expressed appreciation to the men and women of OCPA for their readiness to protect the community. During the winter, the Orange County Mosquito and Vector Control District received an increased number of complaints related to rat infestation in residential areas due to rodents seeking shelter in warmer environments. However, several effective methods for residents are available to protect homes from infestation. For Orange County Public Libraries is holding a library card design competition with the theme "Blast from the Past" that combines retro 1980s and 1990s elements. Members of the public can submit their artwork by, January 31 fora a chance to have it featured on a special edition library card for Comic Orange 2024. For more information and design specifications, visit OCPLory.comcoranyge.  more information, visit OcVector.org/rats.  Councilmember Treseder  Councilmember Treseder expressed her appreciation to those in attendance, and suggested decorum and politeness be respected in order to hear all speakers. Councilmember Treseder provided the following updates related to the Orange  County Power. Authority (OCPA):  Atits meeting of December 2023, the OCPA Board of Directors adopted its 2024 meeting schedule. Beginning in February 2024, OCPA Board meetings will be held the third Tuesday of each month at 10 a.m. The Board unanimously adopted the independent financial audit for OCPA's most recent fiscal year completed by P&B, a firm specializing in Community Choice Aggregation Audits, which affirmed the accuracy of OCPA's financial statements and the absence of material weaknesses in internal  controls.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  5    City Council Minutes  January 9, 2024  OCPA is continuing to recruit a Chief Executive Officer (CEO) with the goal to have one in place by the end of the month; and the Board will interview a small number oft finalists during its next meeting on January 24. OCPA has received Southern California Edison's (SCE) rate related data for 2024, which are projections for SCE's anticipated rates that are needed to determine OCPAI rates. This information willl be considered att the January  24 OCPA Board meeting.  ADDITIONS AND DELETIONS  There were no additions or deletions to the agenda. PUBLIC COMMENTS - NON-AGENDIZED ITEMS  The following individuals spoke in support of a resolution calling for a permanent cease  fire in Gaza:  Aida Morad Tasneem Ma Maribel C. Mona Yashruti Schnall llaha Omar Fatana Hakeem Amal Alkalla Yusef Hakeem Nasseem S. Laila Hakeem  Mariam, University of California, Irvine student  Susan Sayre, Irvine resident, spoke in support of requesting that the City improve its public outreach to ethnic communities by using their commonly used newspapers and social media sites; in support of a stricter plastics ordinance; and in support of the need The following individuals spoke in opposition to a resolution calling for a permanent cease  for commercial lease control.  fire in Gaza:  Rabbi Ciner Steve G.  Dean M., former president of Beth Jacob of Irvine  Julia M. spoke in opposition to a cease fire resolution; in opposition to the findings of the ethics complaint investigation; and noted the increase in police presence at recent City  Council meetings.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  6    City Council Minutes  January9.2024  Rabbi Tennenbaum, Irvine resident, spoke in opposition to sending City resources Carol L. expressed concern related to the City Council's alleged violations of Assembly  overseas.  Bill 1234, and in support of transparency. CONSENT CALENDAR  3.  Prior to adoption of the Consent Calendar, the following individual spoke on Item  No. 3.1:  Carol Lean, Irvine resident, spoke in support of amending the regular meeting minutes of November 28, 2023, to include Mayor Khan's full Moved by Councimember Kim, seconded by Councilmember Treseder, and unanimously carried to approve City Council Consent Calendar Item Nos. 3.2 through 3.5, and 3.7, with the exception of City Council Consent Calendar Item Nos. 3.1 and 3.6, which were removed for separate  statement related to the situation in Gaza.  discussion. 3.1  MINUTES  This item was removed for separate discussion at the request of Councimember Kim, who spoke in support of amending the regular meeting minutes of November 28, 2023, as suggested to include Mayor Khan's full statement related to the situation in Gaza following public City Council discussion included: reiterating that all recordings for City Council meetings were available on the City's website for public viewing ACTION: Moved by Councimember Kim, seconded by Councimember  comments on non-agendized items.  at any time. Treseder, to:  1) Approve the minutes of a special meeting of the City Council 2) Continue approval of the minutes of a regular meeting of the City Council and regular joint meeting with the City of Irvine as Successor Agency to the dissolved Irvine Redevelopment Agency held on November 28, 2023; and direct staff to revise such minutes to include the Mayor's statement related to the situation in the Middle East in its entirety following public comments on non-agendized items, and return to the City  held on November 28, 2023.  Council with the noted revisions for approval.  Prepared byt the City Clerk's Office  7    City Council Minutes  January 9. 2024  The motion failed as follows:  AYES: NOES:  2 COUNCIL-MEMBERS: Kim and Treseder 3 COUNCILMEMBERS: Agran, Carroll, and  Khan  ABSENT: 0 COUNCILMEMBERS: None ABSTAIN: 0 COUNCILMEMBERS: None  ACTION: Moved by Mayor Khan, seconded by Councilmember  Treseder, and unanimously carried to:  1) Approve the minutes of a special meeting of the City Council 2) Approve the minutes of a regular meeting of the City Council and regular joint meeting with the City of Irvine as Successor Agency to the dissolved Irvine Redevelopment Agency held on  held on November 28, 2023.  November 28, 2023.  3.2  PROCLAMATIONS ACTION: Day."  1) Proclaimed January 13, 2024, as "Korean American Day." 2) Proclaimed January 15, 2024, as "Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.  3.3  WARRANT, AND WIRE TRANSFER RESOLUTION  ACTION:  Adopted RESOLUTION NO. 24-01 - A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF IRVINE, CALIFORNIA, ALLOWING CERTAIN CLAIMS AND DEMANDS AND SPECIFYING THE FUNDS OUT OF WHICH THE SAME ARE TO NOTICE OF PENDING APPROVAL FOR A TRACT MAP IN GREAT  BE PAID  3.4  PARKI NEIGHBORHOODS ACTION: Received and filed.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  8    City Council Minutes  January 9. 2024  3.5  CONSIDER ESTABLISHMENT OF A TEMPORARY LIVE MUSIC  VENUE IN THE GREAT PARK SPORTS COMPLEX  ACTION:  1) Directed stafft to proceed with advancing at temporary live music venue at the Great Park Sports Complex with an approximate 2) Authorized staff to secure a stage and associated equipment with long lead time in an amount not to exceed $600,000. (Unless otherwise directed by a member of the City Council, the vote on this matter will reflect the prior action of each Councimember when he or she sat and voted as a member oft the Board of Directors of the Great Park Corporation. However, if a Councimember is not present at the City Council meeting, his or  capacity of 5,000 for the summer of 2024.  her vote will be reflected as absent.)  Approved 5-0.  3.6  SECOND READING AND ADOPTION OF ORDINANCE NO. 23-26 AMENDING CHAPTER 3-39 OF THE IRVINE ZONING ORDINANCE RELATING TO MEDICINAL CANNABIS BUSINESSES This item was removed for separate discussion at the request of Councimember Carroll, who reiterated his opposition to the ordinance.  There was no City Council discussion.  ACTION: Moved by Councilmember Carroll, seconded by Mayor  Khan, to:  Read by title only, second reading and adoption of ORDINANCE NO. 23-26 - AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF IRVINE, CALIFORNIA, APPROVING ZONE CHANGE 00917178-PZC TO AMEND CHAPTER 3-39, CANNABIS RELATED USES, COMMERCIAL CANNABIS ACTIVITIES, DELIVERIES, AND CULTIVATION PROHIBITED, OF THE IRVINE ZONING ORDINANCE RELATING TO MEDICINAL  CANNABIS BUSINESSES  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  9    City Council Minutes  January 9. 2024  The motion carried as follows:  AYES: NOES:  4 - COUNCILMEMBERS: Agran, Kim, Treseder,  and Khan  1  COUNCI.MEMBERS: Carroll  ABSENT: 0 COUNCILMEMBERS: None ABSTAIN: 0 COUNCILMEMBERS: None COMMUNITY PARTNERSHIP, FUND GRANT NOMINATIONS  3.7  ACTION:  1) Approved Mayor Khan's request for Community Partnership Fund Grant Nomination for Fentany/Solution.org int the amount of$1,200 in support of program costs. (Contract No. 11751) 2) Authorized the City Manager to prepare and sign a funding agreement for the organization listed above.  4.  COUNCIL BUSINESS  4.1  APPROVAL OF APPOINTMENTS OF CITY COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVES TO CITY ADVISORY COMMITTEES AND Mayor Khan noted that the proposed appointments were based on her recommendations following discussions with her City Council Doug Elliott, Irvine resident, in support of Councimember Kim's efforts pertaining to affordable housing, and suggested that she, along with Vice Mayor Agran, continue serving on the Irvine Community Land Trust Jspoke in support of Councilmember Carroll replacing Councilmember City Council discussion included: discussing the methodology related to the proposed appointments; suggested opportunities to balance outside appointments amongst members of the City Council; and noted prior efforts and accomplishments by Councimembers who served on  GOVERNMENTAL AGENCIES  colleagues.  Board.  Kim on the Irvine Community Land Trust Board.  outside agency boards.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  10    City Council Minutes  January 9, 2024  ACTION: Moved by Councimember Kim, seconded by Councilmember  Treseder, to:  1) Appoint City Council delegates and alternates to outside governmental agencies on which the City has representation for the 2024 calendar year, as amended to remove the appointment to the Irvine Community Land Trust for separate 2) Appoint City Council representatives and approve staff appointments to various City of Irvine advisory Commissions, Committees and Task Forces for the 2024 calendar year. 3) Adopt Fair Political Practices Commission Public Official Appointment Form 806 and direct the City Clerk to post an amended form to the City website to report any change in appointments to the governmental agencies providing stipends 4) Adopt - A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF IRVINE, CALIFORNIA, DESIGNATING AND APPOINTING ITS REPRESENTATIVE TO THE ORANGE COUNTY FIRE AUTHORITY BOARD OF DIRECTORS  consideration.  as determined by the City Council.  The motion failed as follows:  AYES: NOES:  2 COUNCILMEMBERS: Kim and Treseder 3 COUNCILMEMBERS: Agran, Carroll, and  Khan  ABSENT: 0 COUNCIL-MEMBERS: None ABSTAIN: 0 COUNCILMEMBER: None  ACTION: Moved by Mayor Khan, seconded by Vice Mayor Agran,  to:  1) Appoint City Council delegates and alternates to outside governmental agencies on which the City has representation 2) Appoint City Council representatives and approve staff appointments to various City of Irvine advisory Commissions, Committees and Task Forces for the 2024 calendar year. 3) Adopt Fair Political Practices Commission Public Official Appointment Form 806 and direct the City Clerk to post an amended form to the City website to report any change in appointments to the governmental agencies providing stipends  fort the 2024 calendar year.  as determined by the City Council.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  11    City Council Minutes  January 9. 2024  4) Adopt RESOLUTION NO. 24-02 - A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF IRVINE, CALIFORNIA, DESIGNATING AND APPOINTING ITS REPRESENTATIVE TO THE ORANGE COUNTY FIRE AUTHORITY BOARD OF  DIRECTORS  The motion carried as follows:  AYES: NOES:  3 COUNCILMEMBERS: Agran, Carroll, and 2 COUNCILMEMBERS: Kim and Treseder  Khan  ABSENT: 0 COUNCI.MEMBERS: None ABSTAIN: 0 COUNCILMEMBERS: None  4.2  ORDINANCE ESTABLISHING CHANGES AND ADDITIONS TO Angelina Banda, Associate Engineer, presented the staff report and responded to questions. Kerwin Lau, Deputy Director of Transportation, EJ spoke in support of the proposed amendments to speed limits; suggested speed limits for electric bicycles; suggested that signal timing bee evaluated, particularly at the corner ofMoffett and Harvard; and noted inconsistent speed limits on Moffett approaching the Costa Mesa (55) City Council discussion included: requesting additional information related to the process of increasing and decreasing speed limits; suggested the implementation of protected bicycle lanes and traffic calming as additional measures; and inquired about traffic signal timing  POSTED SPEED LIMITS  was also available for questions.  Freeway.  at Harvard and Moffett and speed limits on Moffett.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  12    City Council Minutes  January 9. 2024  ACTION: Moved by Vice Mayor Agran, seconded by  Councilmember Kim, and unanimously carried to:  Introduce for first reading and read by title only ORDINANCE NO. 24-01 - AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF IRVINE, CALIFORNIA, DIRECTING AN AMENDMENT TO THE CITY OF IRVINE ENGINEERING AND TRAFFIC SURVEYS FORSPEED LIMITS, AS MAINTAINED BY THE PUBLIC WORKS & TRANSPORTATION DEPARTMENT AS THE OFFICIAL DOCUMENTATION OF DECLARED PRIMA FACIE SPEED CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST BY COUNCILMEMBER TRESEDER TO UPDATE POLICIES AND PROCEDURES FOR CITY This item was agendized at the request of Councilmember Treseder, who asked for City Council consideration to update policies and procedures for City Council agendas and meetings, which included amended language related to electronic voting and displaying the dais during virtual public comment, except when multimedia files are Susan Sayre, Irvine resident, spoke in support of considering public comments on non-agendized matters following the completion of the agenda; in support of limiting comments on non-agendized items to matters within the City's jurisdiction; and in support of keeping the Doug Elliott, Irvine resident, spoke in support of Councimember Treseder's proposed changes related to keeping the cameras on the EJ and Jeremy Ficarola, Irvine resident, spoke in support of electronic Dee Fox, Irvine resident, spoke in support of implementing similar City Council discussion included: discussing the merits of voting electronically versus roll call voting; requested additional information on how votes are conducted by City Commissions; and noted the  LIMITS  4.3  COUNCIL AGENDAS AND MEETINGS  presented.  camera on the dais during public comments.  dais during public comments and the voting policy.  voting.  changes at Orange County Power Authority meetings.  importance of accountability and understanding.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  13    City Council Minutes  January 9. 2024  ACTION: Moved by Councilmember Treseder, seconded by  Councilmember Kim, and unanimously carried to:  1) Amend the Remote Participation Policy to read, in part: "Members of the public shall be permitted to view public meetings and provide public comments for agendized items and non-agendized items via Zoom or other City-approved virtual platforms. During public comments provided via Zoom or other City-approved virtual platforms, the exclusive focus oft the visual display to remote attendees shall be the City Council dais, except where multimedia materials have been provided 2) Continue approval of proposed amendments to the Voting Policy pending further study by staff of voting practices by City  for display.  Commissions and elsewhere.  4.4  CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST BY MAYOR KHAN TO UTILIZE INTERNATIONAL ALLIANCE OF THEATRICAL STAGE EMPLOYEES (IATSE) LOCAL 5041 FOR. STAGEHAND STAFFINGAT THE TEMPORARY AND PERMANENT AMPHITHEATERS AT This item was agendized at the request of Mayor Khan, who asked for City Council consideration to utilize IATSE Local 504 for stagehand staffing at the temporary and permanent amphitheaters at Great Park.  GREATPARK  Doug Elliott, Irvine resident, spoke in support.  City Council discussion included: questioning whether stagehand staffing provisions were already included in the request for proposals; questioned whether events such as Irvine Nights and Global Village would also be included, and whether labor IATSE Local 504 would replace City staff; and inquired about size and scope mandates. ACTION: Moved by Mayor Khan, seconded by Councilmember  Kim, and unanimously carried to:  Direct the City Manager to utilize International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees (IATSE) Local 504 for stagehand staffing at the temporary and permanent amphitheaters at Great  Park.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  14    City Council Minutes  January 9, 2024  4.5  CONSIDERATION OF A REQUEST BY COUNCILMEMBER TRESEDER TO DISCUSS A MOCK VILLAGE PROPOSAL IN PARTNERSHIP WITH PAYOMKAWICHUM KAAMALAM This item was agendized at the request of Councilmember Treseder, who asked for City Council consideration to discuss a mock village proposal in partnership with Payômkawichum Kaâmalam. Dee Fox, Irvine resident, spoke in opposition to the proposal, and questioned why this particular group was chosen over others. The following individuals spoke in support of the proposal:  Doug Elliott, Irvine resident Tiffany I, Irvine resident  EJ  City Council discussion included: inquiring about programming, staffing, and operationalexpenses: and inquired about the scope of the proposal. ACTION: Moved by Councilmember: Treseder, seconded by Mayor  Khan, and unanimously carried to:  1) Engage Payômkawichum Kaàmalam and the Acjachemen Nation on development of a mock village in Irvine, to include, but not be limited to, identifying a location for the village, creating preliminary designs for the village, and gathering other pertinent details related to building the village. 2) Present this information to the City Council for its review and 3) If the City Council approves the project to move ahead at that time, direct that staff identify funding and seek all of the necessary approvals related to building the mock village ati that 4) Direct staff to reach out to other indigenous nations, including  consideration within 90 days.  time.  the Kizh also known as Tongva.  PUBLIC COMMENTS - NON-AGENDIZED ITEMS (CONTINUED)  The following individuals spoke in support of a resolution calling for a permanent cease  fire in Gaza:  Sahar, Irvine resident  Mia Villegas, Irvine resident, academic researcher at UCI, and executive board  member of UCI/UAW: statewide Michelle Kim Gardner, UCI student  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  15    City Council Minutes  January 9. 2024  Jineen M. Sonia Monica Bilal C. Liana Rania Daniela Arias Samera Madiha Maja Omar Z. Jason W. Minnie K. Alexander Adilah Ahmad Ethan Nguyen Muath Ismail Sabiha S. Adel Hijazi Sammy Shokeh Haz Al Armaghan Rehman Mohammad Sidra Khan Moazzam Khan Mohammad M. M. Sadam R. Salera Jordan Mohammad Hassan Bilal C. Assif Uddin Amr A Sherine T. Hassen M. Farhana Islam Cyrus Ash Mustafa Khan Marwan Zeidan Alyssa G. Areefa Vallur  Mark Gradoni, UCI employee/TA/union  Hafsa Shaik, Irvine Unified School District student  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  16    City Council Minutes  January 9, 2024  Jana Zaidan Waleed Hamied Ibrahim  The following individuals spoke in opposition to a resolution calling for a permanent cease  fire in Gaza: Senny Robin G. Jason Garshfield Doron L. Joe Bader, Irvine resident Wendy Bokota Aimee Galina B. Janine B. Gali H. Eve Hepner Lea C. Stephanie G. Sandra Paperny Yatz F. Julie Heiman Dara Robin Davis Mike H. EJ  Adam Telcher, President of Beth Jacob Congregation of Irvine  Diane Aviles, Client Service Coordinator and Irvine Community Specialist with  Aviles Real Estate Group of Coldwell Banker Irvine  Scott H. spoke in opposition to at to a resolution calling for a permanent cease fire in Gaza Councimember Treseder left the meeting at 9:25 p.m., Councimember Carroll left the meeting at 10:07 p.m., and Councimember Kim left the meeting at 10:20 p.m. At 10:20 p.m., City Manager Chi announced that there was no longer a quorum due to the absence of Councilmembers Carroll, Kim, and Treseder; and City Attorney Melching  and the meeting's progression on procedural and ethical grounds.  clarified that public comments could continue outside the meeting.  Prepared by the City Clerk's Office  17    City Council Minutes ADJOURNMENT  January9.2024  By consensus of the members present (Councilmembers Carroll, Kim, and Treseder absent), Mayor Khan adjourned the City Counci/meeting: at 10:20 p.m.  - MAYOR OF THE CITY OF IRVINE February 13, 2024  ihe CITY CLERK OF THE CITY OF IRVINE  Prepared byt the City Clerk's Office  18