Board of Architectural Review Meeting July 2nd, ,2024 6:00pm on the: 3rd Floor at 200 S. Main Street Summerville, SC  For additional information regarding this meeting please contact the Planning Department at 843.851.4233. All related documents for this meeting are available for review online and the meeting  will be livestreamed via wwsummerilec.sor  Approval of Minutes: 1. June 4th, 2024 BAR Meeting Public Hearing:  (*Please be advised ify you would like to speak at this time you must sign up prior to the  meeting and comments must be regarding items on the agenda*)  Old Business: 1. N/A New Business: 03-012 11-02-00  1. 212 Beaufort Street - Request to approve shed installation after the fact TMS#: 137-09- 2. 108 E. 3rd South Street -Request to add shed dormer to existing residence TMS#:137- 3. 105V W. 5th South Street Request to install a discovery garden and amphitheater within  Azalea Park. TMS#: 137-10-01-008  Board Review: Old Business: 1.N N/A New Business: 012 02-00  1. 212 Beaufort Street - Request to approve shed installation after the fact TMS#: 137-09-03- 2. 108 E. 3rd South Street -Request to add shed dormer to existing residence TMS#:137-11- 3. 105 - W.: 5th South Street Request to install a discovery garden and amphitheater within  Azalea Park. TMS#: 137-10-01-008  Miscellancous: N/A Adiourn: Agenda Posted:    Board of Architectural Review Meeting Minutes June 4th,2024  Members Present: Phil Dixon, Chairman David Price, Vice Chairman Beth Huggins Rachel Burton Nancyjean Nettles Jane Knight Members Absent: Tim Kennedy Staff Present: Becca Zimmerman, Plannerl II Items on the agenda: Approval of] Minutes: 1. May 7th, 2024 Meeting Public Hearing &J Board Review:  Old Business: N/A New] Business:  1.112 Salisbury Drive- Request tol build addition to existing residence' TMS #: 1371304015 2. 2001 E. 4th South Street- Request toi renovate existing sunroom/replace windows at  existing residence TMS#: 1371106004  Miscellaneous: N/A  At 6:00pm Chairman Dixon opened the meeting. Chairman Dixon asked for consideration oft the minutes from thel May 7th, 2024 BAR meeting. Dr. Price made a motion to approve the minutes as submitted.  Ms. Huggins seconded the motion; the motion passed unanimously.  PublicHearing No Comments Submitted Board LReview: Old Business: N/A New Business:  1)112 Salisbury Lane- Mr. Bullock (contractor) presented thej proposal toi install aj porch cover/carport structure on the rear oft thej property. Ms. Burton and Dr. Price: noted that the structure design was missing architectural details that are typical oft the historic district. Ms. Burton noted that a rendering including the existing building would bel helpful ini reviewing the project along with more architectural details. Conversation continued' between the board members and the applicant regarding the design of the porch    cover/carport. Dr. Price made a motion to defer a decision on the project until further details were provided 2)2001 E. 4th South Street- Mr. Long (owner) presented! his proposal to replace the existing windows ofa sunroom on the back ofhis residence with al knee wall and new windows to create a finished space. The board members discussed the existing windows on the residence and relating the new design to the existing home. Ms. Nettles made a motion to approve the project with the condition that the new windows have 6  as discussed. Ms. Burton seconded the motion; the motion passed unanimously.  over 6 grid ratios. Dr. Price seconded the motion; the motion passed unanimously.  Miscellaneous: N/A  Adjourn: The meeting adjourned at 7pm.  Respectfully Submitted, Becca Zimmerman, Planner II Date: 6/26/24 Approved:  Philip G. Dixon PE, CFM, Chairman    WNI IN  ERVI STAFF REPORT BAR Meeting 7/2/24  To: Town of Summerville BAR From: Becca Zimmerman, Planner II  Date: 5/30/24  GENERAL INFORMATION Lutricia Tucker Blakey  Applicant: Owner: Requested Action:  GREEN LYDIA (ESTATE) C/OBLAKELY LUTRICIA TUCKER  Final Review  Existing Zoning/Land Use: GR-2, Residential  Location:  212 Beaufort Street No Rating (No Survey)  SHPO Survey Rating: Proposed Alterations: Guideline Citation:  Request to approve shed as installed  5.10 UNIVERSAL GUIDELINES FOR NEW STANDALONE CONSTRUCTION Guideline 32. New Garage or Outbuilding  Construction  Evaluation:  This property is on the edge oft the historic district, and due to a clerical error, the permit was issued for this project without BAR approval by no fault oft the applicant. They were not aware that their property was within the historic district and subject to the approval of the BAR. The shed is otherwise Zoning compliant, it does feature a The majority of the surrounding properties have similar accessory Due to the location ofbuildings, proximity and mature landscaping in the area, it does not appear that the shed is visible from either  bathroom but is not an accessory dwelling unit. sheds on the rear of their properties.  Beaufort Street or Knights Lane.    Knightsl 1n  Beaufort St  Beaufort SE    LANE 78.55  E 767817E new shed  SITÉ BEAUFORT STREET  LOCATION MAP 210 BEAUFORT STREET THIS LOT IS LOCATED IN FLOOD ZONE CSEEFFIRM COMMUNITY PANEL NO.-450073 0005 D MAP REVISED: DECEMBER 4, 1985. TMS THE NO. SAME 37-09-03-016 BEING SHOWN ON A PLAT DATED SEPTEMBER 15, 1980 BY AND THOMAS RECORDED W: BAILEY IN THE RMC OFFICE FOR DORCHESTER COUNTY IN PLAT BOOK D. AT PAGE 35. NOTE: THIS LOT WAS SURVEYED AÇCORDING TO LINES OF existing OCCUPATION AND PHYSICAL MONUMENTATION.  TMS NO. 137- 09-03-012 0.462 Ac  shed  TMS. NO. 137-09-03-012 Bo ESTATE OF LYDIA GREEN    2 STORY WOOD SIDING HOUSE 513.0  SEoNp GERALD E. BLACKELL TOWN ENGINEER/ZONIO CFFICER TOWN OF SUMMERVL SC DAE4-73-98  265 CUFTON TOTHE STREET R/W. 87/30'00'E,  $8730'00'w 80.03 oEE 79.01 BEAUFORT STREET R/W VARIES  PLAT SHOWING 0.462 Ac OWNED BY LAURA A. SCHOONMAKER & DAVID L. SCHOONMAKER TOWN OF SUMMERVILLE DORCHESTER COUNTY, SOUTH CAROLINA SCALE : 1" = 30' - 30' APRIL 23, 1998 ASHLEY URVEYING.  HEREBY STATE TO THE BEST OF MY KNOMLEDGE, INFORMATION AND BELIEF IN ACCORDANCE THE SURVEY WITH SHOWN THE HEREON REQUIREMENTS WAS MADE OF THE MINIMUM STANDARDS MANUAL FOR CAROLINAL. THE PRACTICE AND OF MEETS LAND OR SURVEYING EXCEEDS IN SOUTE THE REQUIREMENTS FOR A CLASS A SURVEY AE ENCROAÇHMENIS OR Barpcchunel PAUL C TAWSON, JR.S.C. REG.  Ps WGN 0-10 JOR NO. 98052-210  I CAROL, ASHLEY INC. No. C00758/!,  CAROL LAND SURVEYOR  60' INC.  SURVEYING, SPEÇIFIED THEREIN: PROJECTIONS ALSO THERE OTHER ARE THAN NO VISIBLE SHOWN.                WNI IN  ERVI STAFF REPORT BAR Meeting 7/2/24  To: Town of Summerville BAR From: Becca Zimmerman, Planner II  Date: 5/30/24  GENERAL INFORMATION Tyler A Smyth Architects HOFFMAN LORI & JOEL Final Review  Applicant: Owner: Requested Action:  Existing Zoning/Land Use: GR-2, Residential  Location:  108 E. 3rd South Street No Rating (No Survey)  SHPO Survey Rating: Proposed Alterations: Guideline Citation: Evaluation:  Request to install shed dormer on the rear ofhome 5.14GUIDELINES FOR RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES Thej proposed shed dormer addition to the second story oft the existing residence ties in with the existing design and materials oft the residence. The addition will not be visible from the right-of- way except when approaching the property from Magnolia Street towards Main Street along E. 3rd South Street. The proposal is Zoning compliant and follows general BAR guidelines.  Guideline 55.. Dormers    175  Vhs  17    HOFFMAN RESIDENCE CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS SET  JUNE 7, 2024 GENERAL PROJECT NOTES  DIMENSIONS  FENESTRATION  DRAWINGINDEX  PLUMBINGA  STRUCTURAL COORDINATION  ELECTRICAL  MATERIALS  HVAC  APPLICABLECODES  A001    'RONRODFOUND N:431,293.54 E:2,252,253.21 (GRID)  EOEA  BETHELA AME METHODIST CHURCH PBLPG049 TMS137-11-02-001  1"OPENTOPPIPE FOUND  MARKC.MOSER 3251 DB401PG144 TMS1 137-11-02-003  LORI&JOELHOFFMAN (JTROS) DB15226PG235 TMS137-11-02-002 AREAINPARCEL=/ 21,046.2657S.F. 10.483AC.  SITEPLAN& SURVEYNOTES SITEPLAN,I INCLUDINGI PROPERTYE BOUNDARIES, SETBACKS, ANDALL OTHERINFORMATION, ISBASEDUPONSURVEX PERFORMEDBY: COLANDLNOAIRCRGDANTN MAY29.2024 ARCHITECT ASSUMESNO RESPONSIBILITYFORA ACCURACYOFI INFORMATION PROVIDEDBY THES SURVEYOR. SEELANDSCAPE DRAWINGS FORA ADDITIONAL INFORMATION. INCLUDING TREESTOBEREMOVED, AND TREE CARE NOTES, TOPOGRAPHICAL/ /GRADING NOTES, ETC. LANDSCAPE ARCHITECTT TOOVERSEE REMOVAL OF ANY TREESFROMSITE CONTRACTORT TOMASPPORSIAECOUTAL ACCURACY. SEGROUNDFLOORPILANONSHEETAIOFOR FOUNDATIONDIMENSONS  ANDT TREEI INFORMATION,  STRM BOX "IRONROD FOUND  SAMPABTOMPONSEAEOO (JTROS) DB14126PG349 TMS1 137-11-02-004  TREBOR8ANNEMARIE BLAZE (JTROS) DB12997PG248 TMS1 137-11-02-005  SITE PLAN- OVERALL 3/32"-1-0"  A101    go LMNGROOM  PANTRY  GUESTBED  D D D  FIRST FLOOR PLAN, PROPOSED 1/4"-1-0"  A110    GUESTBATH  OWNERSBATH  OWNER'SBED  ATTIC FLOOR PLAN, PROPOSED 1/4"-1-0"  A111    D3  ROOF PLAN, PROPOSED 1/4"  A112    EXTERIORDIMENSIONS PROVIDED  D D  D  FIRST FLOOR PLAN, EXISTING 1/4"-  A130    D  UNFINISHEDATTIC  ATTIC FLOOR PLAN, EXISTING 1/4"-1-0"  A131    Da  ROOF PLAN, EXISTING 1/4"  A132    E  A133    Da  a  A135    SECONDLEVEL 6  LOWER  NOCHANGES VSBIEFROMSTRETEIEVA  FRONT (NORTH) ELEVATION  PROPOSED  REAR (SOUTH) ELEVATION PROPOSED  1/4  VEL 6  FRONT (NORTH) ELEVATION-EXISTING  REAR (SOUTH) ELEVATION-EXISTING  1/4"-1-0  1/4"=1-0  A210    SECOND 6    SIDE (WEST) ELEVATION PROPOSED  1/4  LEVEL 6  SIDE (WEST) ELEVATION EXISTING 1/4"-1-0"  A211      EVEL 6  SIDE (EAST)ELEVATION- -PROPOSED  1/4"-  6  SIDE (EAST) ELEVATION EXISTING  1/4"  A212    3  LANDING  OWNERSBATH  EVEL  PANTRY  SECTION 1 PROPOSED 1/4"=  UNFINISHEDATTIC  e  SECTION 1 EXISTING 1/4"-1-0"  A301    TYP EAVE DETAIL 11/2"=  LEVEL  PROPOSED SHED DORMER WALL SECTION  3/4"= 1-0"  A311    go LMNGROOM  PANTRY  GUESTBED  D D D  FIRST FLOOR PLAN, PROPOSED 1/4"-1-0"  A110    GUESTBATH  OWNERSBATH  OWNER'SBED  ATTIC FLOOR PLAN, PROPOSED 1/4"-1-0"  A111    D3  ROOF PLAN, PROPOSED 1/4"  A112    EXTERIORDIMENSIONS PROVIDED  D D  D  FIRST FLOOR PLAN, EXISTING 1/4"-  A130    D  UNFINISHEDATTIC  ATTIC FLOOR PLAN, EXISTING 1/4"-1-0"  A131    Da  ROOF PLAN, EXISTING 1/4"  A132    E  A133    Da  a  A135            1            ITITATE  RTE                    Backto! Map  Googk        WNI IN  ERVI STAFF REPORT BAR Meeting 7/2/24  To: Town of Summerville BAR From: Becca Zimmerman, Planner II  Date: 5/30/24  GENERAL INFORMATION Leadership Dorchester 2024 Town of Summerville Final Review  Applicant: Owner: Requested Action:  Existing Zoning/Land Use: PL, Public Land, Park  Location:  105 W.: 5th South Street (Azalea Park) No Rating/Not a Structure  SHPO Survey Rating: Proposed Alterations: Guideline Citation: Evaluation:  Request to construct a Children's Discovery Garden 5.71 UNIVERSAL GUIDELINES FOR SITE DESIGN The proposed site design/features submitted lend themselves to the natural beauty of Azalea Park. The simple and limited scope of construction work involved for the amphitheater will blend in with the park surroundings, especially as the materials weather over time. The installations do not present any Zoning issues and the overall project is Zoning compliant. It appears the installations will only be visible within thej park. This proposal has received Town  Council approval.    17  fzolea Park  175  Cuthbert Community Center  165  17    WESICENw  TE2 59106087 2n1or  BETHANY UNITED METHODIST CHURCH OF SUMMERVILLE  BARBARA S. ROWLEY  SUBHASHBHAI M. PATEL  S587913"E 529.05'  PHILIP  LAWRENCE, RICHARD F. DANIELS  WESLEY METHODIST CHURCH  JAMES W. BERRY  SOUTH COUNTY  WEST 5TH SOUTH STREET  PLAT SHOWING DETMOLD BLOCKS 38 AND 92,THE UNOPENED RIGHT-OF-WAYS OF FOURTH SOUTH AND FIFTH SOUTH, AND THE UNOPENED RIGHT-OF-WAY FOR CEDAR STREET, BEING THE AZALEA PARK, OWNED BY THE TOWN OF SUMMERVILLE  OF SUMMERVILLE S.c. 29484 SCMCYSISSES  239.09' RICHARD S. HUNTÉR GARRY TERESA  P.0. BOX 6,  FAULCOMER FRIAR  JANUABY2 2002990    AZALEAPARK-  CHILDREN'S  DISCOVERY  GARDEN  LEADERSHIP DORCHESTER 2024    Area that Azalea  Park Children's  Discovery Garden  Attached on the coming slide is two maps that will showthe area of the park that will be utilized for the Discovery  will be utilizing  Garden    .05  118.54  5Z02:48"E  DRANAGE CANAL  JRCH  RIGHT ISA BROAD SHOT LEFT ISAZOOMED IN SHOT    TURTLE SCULPTURE MUSHROOM: STEPPINGSTONES 3MUSICHECES AMPHITHEATER HOPSCOTCH TURTLE STEPPING STONES BALANCE BEAM WRAPPED TREE BENCH PROPOSED WALKINGT TRAIL  TURILES SCULPTURE  STEPPING STONE  EXISTING  PIECES  URTLE STEPPING STONES  EXISIING  EXISIING  B W5THSSTREET    TWO MAIN AREAS FOR EQUIPMENT PIECES.  (SHOWN ON MAP IN NEXT SLIDE)    MAIN AREA  BETHANY UNITED METHODIST CHURCH OF SUMMERMLLE  BARBARA  shgst  FOR  EQUIPMENT  RICHARD F. DANIELS  PIECES  LEY METHODIST CHURCH  JAMES W. BERRY    LEGEND TURTESCUIPIURE SIONES 3MUSICHECIS AMPHIHEATER  CHILDRENS DISCOVERY GARDEN    EQUIPMENT PIECES (MAIN  AREA)  Painted Turtle Made of GFRC (Glass Reinforced concrete)  EWTO  Paintedl Turle TC029  Dimensions: 16-6"X 18'area  SCA  Turtle is 4'-6"X6' X2'        GFRC sculpture plan outine  Integral footing  APPROXIMATE WEIGHT: 1,800LBS  Plan SCALE:1/4" = 1-0"  Note: When determining critical fall height please allow for +2" tolerance inc concrete surface GFRC sculpture outine Safety surfacing (by others) Finished grade Compacted subgrade (by others)  Painted Turtle TC029  3    AMPHITHEAIRE/CHILDRENS STAGE (EQUIPMENT PIECE MAIN AREA)  CHILDRENSAMPHIHEATRE ALLOWKIDSTO USE THEIR MAGINATIONAND COLABORATEW/OTHER CHILDREN MORE UNIQUE AND USEFUL TO THE CHILDREN THAN A PLAYHOUSE ITISALSO OPEN AND SAFER FOR CHILDREN LEADERSHIP DORCHESTER 2024WILL BE CONSTRUCTINGIT.ALL WOODWILL BE PRESSURE TREATED.    AMPHITHEAIEATER/SIAGE STRUCTURE  Stage will be 10'X10'X1. Whichy will include: a backdrop w/ a weather resistant writable surface that is 12'wide and 6'tall for children, teachers, and parents to present/instruct  on  Willalso have several rows of bench seating as shown in the picture    AMPHIHEAIEAIER/SIAGE STRUCTURE  Footer detail: Pressure Treated 4) X4 will be anchored into a 24"X12" footer via a Simpson EBU 44Z. Willlook exactly like the pictures shown.  10'  5/"PRESSURE TREATED DECKINGE BOARDS TOTAL COUNT =22 JOIST16" ONC  10'  10'  10'  BANDBOARD SUPPORTBOARD TYP4X4POST  ONE STEP. 6"FROM GROUND 6"FROM TOP OF STAGE TOI MEET CODE. 111 INCH RUN  STEP BOARD 5DECKING PRESSURE TREATED    ELEVATIONS OF STAGE/AMPHIHEAIER  DASHI INDICATING WHERE BANDE BOARDS MEET ANDI WRAPSAROUND OTHERS SIDE  PRESSURE IREAIEDDECKINGI BOARD  PRESSURET TREATEDDECANGBOARD  -CARRIAGEBOLT 2X8BANDBOARD 4X4POST  STEP11'RUN 6'RISE BOTTOM OF 2X8BANDB BOARD  24"X12" CONCRETE FOOTING WI SIMPSON EBU4 44Z  -EARTH  EARTH    AMPHITHEATEATER/STAGE SEATING STRUCTURE  Benches: They will be made out of treated lumber for seating as seen above. Will be sitting on treated 4X4's with the same footings as stage. Supports will be placed on either side of each 4X4 for more stability.    SMALLER EQUIPMENT PIECES  MUSHROOM STEPPERS SET OFT THREE: LARGE, MEDIUM, & SMALL  STICKS W/ THE OUTDOOR THEME THAT CORRELATES W/  THE TURTLES  INSTALLS INTO A CONCRETE PIER W/ A 12"JB BOLT  Mushroom Steppers        SMALLER  EQUIPMENT PIECES  8'F FALLEN TREE BALANCE  BEAM  STICKS W/ THE NATURE THEME INSTALLS INTOACONCREIE PIER W/AY"JBOLT    SMALLER  EQUIPMENT PIECES  STEPPINGTURILES  CORRELATES W/ THE PAINTED  TURTLE  INSTALLS INTO A CONCRETE PIER W/ A V"JBOLT    WALKING PATH. AREAS    4024A1 222.68  OTHER  ZONES TO BE UTILIZED FOR GAMES/STEM ACTIVITIES  DRANAGE CAMAL  : T9        EQUIPMENT PIECES  PERCUSSION PLAY SET OF3. WILL SPREAD THEM THROUGHOUTTHE ZONES OFF OF THE WALKING PATHSTO ATTRACT CHILDREN MOUNTI INTO ACONCRETE  PIER    GAMESISTEM ACTIVTES  HOPSCOTCH MADE OUT OF PAVERS TO KEEP THAT NATURE FEEL  WILL KEEP MOST OF THIS AREA FOR FUTURE GROWTH FOR OTHERS TO IMPROVE UPON AS THEY SEE FIT  0Os    OTHER FEATURE  SEATING:WRAPPED BENCHES ALLOWSI FORI PARENTSTO BE ABLETOI MOVE EFFICIENTLYAND/ ALWAYS HAVEALINEOF SIGHT FOR THEIR CHILDREN BENCHWILL NOTBEINTHE GROUND ORI NOTTOUCHTHET TREE LEADERSHIP2 24" WILL BE CONSTRUCTING BEI BUILTOUT OF PRESSURE TREATEDL LUMI SEAT WILL BE 18'WIDE BACK WILL BE: 20" HIGH HAVE AND/ ANGLEC OF 110DEGREES 18" OFF THE GROUND 2X8 WILLI BE PLACED, AT THE TOPOFT THE HEADREST FORI MORE ROOMANDWILL BE BRACEDI UNDER WILLI BE OCTAGON: SHAPED NOFOOTERI WILL BEI REQUIRED PHOTOTO THE LEFTIST THE INSPIRATION PHOTO    BROWN FAMILY PARK For many years the Brown ta mily livedon, farmed, and nurtured this land. This park Is dedicated to the memory of Murrett Joseph.Brown, Ernestine Elizabeth Brown, Vermelle Brown, Jeannette Brown, and Waymon C. Browh.  PLAQUESTO  PROMOTE DONORS  &SPONSORS  May 27, 2015  PLAQUE: BRICK BASE W/ A HARD CONCRETE BACKGROUND AND NICE LETTERING THAT  Dedicated  by Burnett E owr  WILL NOT FADE OR WEAR    LEGEND TURTLES SCULPTURE STEPPING 3MUSICI PIECES AMPHITHEATER HOPSCOTCH TURTLE STEPPINGS STONES BALANCEE BEAM WRAPPEDT TREE BENCH PROPOSED) TRAIL  CHILDREN'S DISCOVERY GARDEN  EMISTINGCAN N  TURTLES SCULPTURE  STEPPING STONES  EXISTING HEATER  EXISTING TENNIS  3MUSICPIECES  HOPSCOTCH  TURTLES STEPPING STONES  BUILDING  PARKING  B WSTHSSTREET  WRAPPEDT TREEE BENCH  AZALEA PARK - CHILDREN'S DISCOVERY GARDEN  June 2024 SCALE: 1"=30-0  THOMAS HUTTON  SUMMERVILLIE SOUTH CAROLINA    10'  51 PRESSURE TREATED DECKING BOARDS TOTAL COUNT = 22  10'  JOIST 16" ONC  10'  10  BOARD  TYP 4X4 POST  PCO,  ONE STEP. 6"FROM GROUND 6" FROM TOP OF STAGE TO MEET CODE. 11 INCH RUN  STEP  5/-DECKING BOARD PRESSURE TREATED  SCALE 1"= 1'-0" TUPCO, Commercial Design/Build GeneralContractor  LEADERSHIP DORCHESTER 24'  AZALEA PARK June 28, 2024  AMPHITHEATER/STAGE  Inc    DASH INDICATING WHERE BAND BOARDS MEET AND WRAPS AROUND OTHER SIDE  PRESSURE TREATEDDECKING BOARI  CARRIAGE  2X8 BAND BOARD 4X4 POST  24"X12" CONCRETE FOOTING WI SIMPSON EBU 44Z  TUPCO,  SCALE 1 1/2"=1-0" TUPCO Commercial Design/Build  LEADERSHIP DORCHESTER 24'  AZALEA PARK June 28, 2024  STAGE  GeneralContractor    PRESSURE TREATED DECKING BOARD  6"STEP  BOTTOM OF 2X8 BAND BOARD  TUPCO,  SCALE 1 1/2"=1-0" TUPCO Commercial Design/Build  LEADERSHIP DORCHESTER 24'  AZALEA PARK June 28, 2024  STAGE  GeneralContractor